Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
This is garbage. OP is not, in any way, responsible if her adult spouse makes the decision to kill himself. The idea that she should blame herself, and that she is responsible to her children for the behavior of her husband, is beyond regressive.
If she sits home staring at her husband and she goes to the bathroom, and he kills himself, doesn’t she still have to tell her children? Or does the good wife fairy come and tell them for her?
Hilarious and stupid that you're calling it garbage, yet a mental health professional posting above you says it's spot on.
Which of you should OP trust for advice, I wonder?
No one said OP was actually "responsible" if he kills himself. I only said that she will have to deal with her own feelings and their kids' reactions if he does. If you think that people do not feel guilty after someone's suicide--even when they themselves could never have prevented it and didn't cause it -- you truly know nothing about suicide or how profoundly it affects those left behind.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
This is garbage. OP is not, in any way, responsible if her adult spouse makes the decision to kill himself. The idea that she should blame herself, and that she is responsible to her children for the behavior of her husband, is beyond regressive.
If she sits home staring at her husband and she goes to the bathroom, and he kills himself, doesn’t she still have to tell her children? Or does the good wife fairy come and tell them for her?
Hilarious and stupid that you're calling it garbage, yet a mental health professional posting above you says it's spot on.
Which of you should OP trust for advice, I wonder?
No one said OP was actually "responsible" if he kills himself. I only said that she will have to deal with her own feelings and their kids' reactions if he does. If you think that people do not feel guilty after someone's suicide--even when they themselves could never have prevented it and didn't cause it -- you truly know nothing about suicide or how profoundly it affects those left behind.
Anonymous wrote:I'm suspicious that he doesn't want to stay married but is too chickens&*t to leave, so he's acting out and trying to make OP end it.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
This is garbage. OP is not, in any way, responsible if her adult spouse makes the decision to kill himself. The idea that she should blame herself, and that she is responsible to her children for the behavior of her husband, is beyond regressive.
If she sits home staring at her husband and she goes to the bathroom, and he kills himself, doesn’t she still have to tell her children? Or does the good wife fairy come and tell them for her?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
DP - all of this. The amount and degree of speculation on this thread is staggering. Even those of us on this thread who actually are mental health professionals don’t know what’s really going on because *we’re not examining OP’s husband*. And guess what? Even the healthcare professionals treating him won’t know the full picture from an initial evaluation! That’s not how it works.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.
Wow, you're able to diagnose a person who claims he's suicidal, without even meeting him? You are truly a miraculous mental health professional, PP!
![]()
Even if he IS faking or playing her, SHE cannot know that for sure. And the results, if you are wrong about his being "fine," are way too serious to risk. OP has to take him at face value for right now or risk having to explain to her kids why dad isn't ever coming home, and OP would have to deal with the guilt of not taking him seriously, if he does harm himself.
I have no idea if he's just manipulating her--he might be-- but neither do you or anyone here. That's not our call. It's not even really OP's call. It's a medical professional's call.
Anonymous wrote:OP, it’s never just one crisis. It was a cascade of never-ending crises - some bigger than others but all calling for my help, or at least I thought so at the time.
I say this as someone whose DH cheated and had a subsequent mental health crisis.
Many who have loved ones living with mental illness live by the motto, “secure your own oxygen mask first.” Securing your own mask doesn’t mean you won’t help others. It means you can help others best when you make sure your physical, emotional, financial, career etc. needs are being reasonably met.
If you keep giving up your own needs and stability in favor of someone else, you will be in trouble yourself and no longer able to help the other.
Please consider taking the NAMI Family to Family course.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:He wants the heat off of him for messing up. He wants out of the current situation with little backlash. If you don’t stay now and ease up on him about the past few years of deceit, then you now get to become the bad guy in story. This is his was of coping and shifting the mess onto you to hush you up.
I am suspicious that this is what is happening, too.
Anonymous wrote:He wants the heat off of him for messing up. He wants out of the current situation with little backlash. If you don’t stay now and ease up on him about the past few years of deceit, then you now get to become the bad guy in story. This is his was of coping and shifting the mess onto you to hush you up.
Anonymous wrote:Haven't read the whole thread but sounds like DH is sabotaging your career
He's fine.