Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:So, interviewers, what DOES it take to get into one of the higly selective colleges from a DC public school?
Little Ivy Interviewer here. Here's what I've seen other applicants do that DCPS and Latin kids generally don't:
*Score 700s on all three sections of the SAT if high-SES, and at least mid 600s if low-SES/FARMs. Take the SAT multiple times if necessary. Making the 700 cuts only means that an application is read - Ivies/Little Ivies now reject around 3/4 of the kids with at least one perfect SAT score. A kid's chances of admission rise from around 10% to 15% if they score in the 750-800 range on a section rather than in the 700-750 range. Banneker's average SAT scores are in the 480-520 range. Don't know what Latin's are, but not 700s.
*Pick a favorite school and apply Early Action/Decision in October, even if binding. Chances of admission double by applying early.
*If language immersion in ES, have immersion experiences in MS and HS during summers/breaks. Low-SES kids can apply for foundation grants to participate in immersion camps, domestically and abroad. MoCo and Fairfax fund such camps for low-SES kids, DC isn't doing this. If high-SES with enough space in the home, hire a series of part-time au pairs speaking the immersion language, possible through the State Dept. program to age 12, if at least one of the parents isn't fluent in it.
*Participate in the Johns Hopkins CTY camps (nearest at campus of St. Stephens and St. Agnes in VA), preferably from the summer after 2nd grade through MS. The MS camps are sleep-over camps. Hopkins waives the $2,500 - $4,000 fee for FARMs kids. Participate in the Stanford University EPSY on-line programs for gifted youth, particularly for math and science. MS kids can also do Kumon, Saxon and Khan Academy math on-line.
*Take algebra no later than the 7th grade, even if humanities oriented. If a DC PS doesn't offer it before 8th grade, takes it during the summer at a Johns Hopkins camp or via Stanford EPSY.
*If the school offers IB, pursue the full diploma and score 40+ (schools can revoke admissions offers for a low total score). Even if a school offers IB, take AP language exams (no longer any need to take AP courses to take exams) or SAT II language exams and get 700s+ (or retake). Do this because IB test scores don't come out until after HS graduation, which can handicap IB kids. If a school does not offer IB, take at least 7 AP tests, preferably 10. Score all 4s and 5s, even if low-SES. Retake any tests where the score is a 3 or lower. If a humanities student, take 2 IB and AP language tests, or just 2 AP.
*Pursue unusual extra-curriculars and summer activities, preferably one of a kind involving travel/volunteering.
*If science-oriented, enter at least one of the national science or team robotics competitions with a mentor from 10th grade, or the NIH high school research program. Do not stop at AB calculus and physics (one year), take the second year/level, BC, through self-study if necessary.
Not every applicant does all this of course, but I've never seen one fail who did and I've interviewed around 80. One caveat: the "rules" for top HS athletes, actors and musicians are different. Hope this helps.
Wow, I got into an Ivy 15 years ago for undergrad (humanities/social sciences) and I didn't do the majority of your list--just good SAT score, grades, school leadership and volunteering. And I attended a standard/average parochial school for MS/HS. What happened??!!
Anonymous wrote:^^You're being harsh and the obsenities aren't needed. This PP makes a good point. We pulled our middle schooler grader out of 2 Rivers for a private, although it was a friendly, happy school, because of the lack of ability grouping. We were concerned that he was not on track to be admitted either to the Ivies one of us attended for undergrad and grad school or the military academy the other attended. Our younger child is at a language immersion school and we' are also concerned about open lottery admissions at DCI. If you aren't concerned, great, but other parents are, and invalidating their concerns isn't reasonable.
One of our best friends is a teacher at Latin. She talks openly about problems associated with putting low-performing and high-performing kids into the same classrooms (Latin only differentiates for 8th grade algebra in MS). She doesn't think that Latin's HS is on the road to "launching Ivy League careers" because that's not the orientation of the school. The administrators, guidance counselors (the most senior of whom is a Mt. Holyoke grad) and teachers aspire to see graduates attend small liberal arts colleges (e.g. Hamilton), not Ivies, top technical schools like MIT and CalTech, or military academies. Will Basis DC be different? Who knows.
Unfortunately, SWW and Wilson aren't as different from Latin as we'd like. We'd love to see one high-powered public HS in the city emerge. Will DCI be it? Hard to imagine open lottery admissions doing the trick.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:So, interviewers, what DOES it take to get into one of the higly selective colleges from a DC public school?
Little Ivy Interviewer here. Here's what I've seen other applicants do that DCPS and Latin kids generally don't:
*Score 700s on all three sections of the SAT if high-SES, and at least mid 600s if low-SES/FARMs. Take the SAT multiple times if necessary. Making the 700 cuts only means that an application is read - Ivies/Little Ivies now reject around 3/4 of the kids with at least one perfect SAT score. A kid's chances of admission rise from around 10% to 15% if they score in the 750-800 range on a section rather than in the 700-750 range. Banneker's average SAT scores are in the 480-520 range. Don't know what Latin's are, but not 700s.
*Pick a favorite school and apply Early Action/Decision in October, even if binding. Chances of admission double by applying early.
*If language immersion in ES, have immersion experiences in MS and HS during summers/breaks. Low-SES kids can apply for foundation grants to participate in immersion camps, domestically and abroad. MoCo and Fairfax fund such camps for low-SES kids, DC isn't doing this. If high-SES with enough space in the home, hire a series of part-time au pairs speaking the immersion language, possible through the State Dept. program to age 12, if at least one of the parents isn't fluent in it.
*Participate in the Johns Hopkins CTY camps (nearest at campus of St. Stephens and St. Agnes in VA), preferably from the summer after 2nd grade through MS. The MS camps are sleep-over camps. Hopkins waives the $2,500 - $4,000 fee for FARMs kids. Participate in the Stanford University EPSY on-line programs for gifted youth, particularly for math and science. MS kids can also do Kumon, Saxon and Khan Academy math on-line.
*Take algebra no later than the 7th grade, even if humanities oriented. If a DC PS doesn't offer it before 8th grade, takes it during the summer at a Johns Hopkins camp or via Stanford EPSY.
*If the school offers IB, pursue the full diploma and score 40+ (schools can revoke admissions offers for a low total score). Even if a school offers IB, take AP language exams (no longer any need to take AP courses to take exams) or SAT II language exams and get 700s+ (or retake). Do this because IB test scores don't come out until after HS graduation, which can handicap IB kids. If a school does not offer IB, take at least 7 AP tests, preferably 10. Score all 4s and 5s, even if low-SES. Retake any tests where the score is a 3 or lower. If a humanities student, take 2 IB and AP language tests, or just 2 AP.
*Pursue unusual extra-curriculars and summer activities, preferably one of a kind involving travel/volunteering.
*If science-oriented, enter at least one of the national science or team robotics competitions with a mentor from 10th grade, or the NIH high school research program. Do not stop at AB calculus and physics (one year), take the second year/level, BC, through self-study if necessary.
Not every applicant does all this of course, but I've never seen one fail who did and I've interviewed around 80. One caveat: the "rules" for top HS athletes, actors and musicians are different. Hope this helps.
Anonymous wrote:I don't understand the obsession with Ivies that I've seen on this board (or Little Ivies for that matter). It is great to have that as a goal but there are many great universities where students will also get a good education.
Anonymous wrote:So, interviewers, what DOES it take to get into one of the higly selective colleges from a DC public school?
Anonymous wrote:An IBO program by definition does ability tracking, with the IB degree at the end - the highest level - so we're not particularly worried but happy there is a public middle/high school option that we can consider over private school. We're not interested in Basis or Latin.Anonymous wrote:
I had no idea the senior guidance counselor was from Holyoke! I'll be just as happy if DC attends Amherst, Williams, Swathmore, etc. over the Ivies, DH and I attended...
Anonymous wrote:An IBO program by definition does ability tracking, with the IB degree at the end - the highest level - so we're not particularly worried but happy there is a public middle/high school option that we can consider over private school. We're not interested in Basis or Latin.Anonymous wrote:
I had no idea the senior guidance counselor was from Holyoke! I'll be just as happy if DC attends Amherst, Williams, Swathmore, etc. over the Ivies, DH and I attended...
Latin does ability tracking in HS, not in MS, other than for algebra, which helps drive out most of the high-SES families somewhere between 6th and 9th grades. Anybody who disputes this need only look at the percentage of white kids, over a third for MS and around 10% for HS, although the figure is rising.
The Ivies take 6-10% of applicants (other than Cornell, 18%, the only public-private school among them), the "Little Ivies" take around 15%, pretty much the same applicant pool. Holyoke takes closer to 40%. I interview Metro area applicants for my Little Ivy and hardly anybody gets in from DCPS, while PS kids from MoCo and Fairfax commonly do. They usually come up through ES and MS G/T programs and have much higher AP and SAT test scores than even the best DCPS kids, including white kids. A good third of them earn the full IB diploma, which is no longer remarkable. Top schools now look at the total IB score more than the diploma and 40+ isn't uncommon.
If DCI really does offer several levels for each subject, terrific, but since no other MS in the city does, and the charter board has offered stiff resistance to any sort of selective admissions, even for a sensible, non-race or class-based reason (bilingualism), it's tough to argue with the skeptics. Even Deal doesn't track much yet.
Why would the charter board allow extensive ability grouping but not selective admissions? In that case, wouldn't the dreaded elitism and cherry-picking simply emerge within the school (with massive over-representation of high-SES families in upper echelon courses)? That doesn't sound politically tenable, no matter how many high-SES families wind up enrolling.
An IBO program by definition does ability tracking, with the IB degree at the end - the highest level - so we're not particularly worried but happy there is a public middle/high school option that we can consider over private school. We're not interested in Basis or Latin.Anonymous wrote: