Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone think the falling ranking of W&M will result in lower caliber applicants, especially OOS?

How is it "fAlling"

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone think the falling ranking of W&M will result in lower caliber applicants, especially OOS?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My kid got in RD OOS last year. Male, 3.8 UW, 1500+ SAT.

PP- my point is, still very accessible for OOS applicants who don’t have a flawless transcript or 12+ AP’s

1500+ isn’t exactly accessible

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My kid got in RD OOS last year. Male, 3.8 UW, 1500+ SAT.

PP- my point is, still very accessible for OOS applicants who don’t have a flawless transcript or 12+ AP’s

Anonymous wrote:My kid got in RD OOS last year. Male, 3.8 UW, 1500+ SAT.

Anonymous wrote:What do you think of DD's chances?

MCPS OOS
3.9 UWGPA; 4.7 WGPA
Test optional
Strong ECs - regional/national recognition
Good recommendations
Musician
Demonstrated interest (but not ED)

Naviance says W&M is a solid target.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:What do you think of DD's chances?

MCPS OOS
3.9 UWGPA; 4.7 WGPA
Test optional
Strong ECs - regional/national recognition
Good recommendations
Musician
Demonstrated interest (but not ED)

Naviance says W&M is a solid target.

Looks like a target if in-state, not sure about OOS. Maybe a reach due to that and TO.

Anonymous wrote:What do you think of DD's chances?

MCPS OOS
3.9 UWGPA; 4.7 WGPA
Test optional
Strong ECs - regional/national recognition
Good recommendations
Musician
Demonstrated interest (but not ED)

Naviance says W&M is a solid target.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:W&M parent here. Why do we have to go over this every couple months again and again?

Yes, UVA has a lower acceptance rate as it offers engineering and bigger sports, etc. which W&M does not. So, it appeals to a larger group of prospective students. No hard feelings, why would there be? (at least not from me).

W&M has always been a bit more self-selecting due to its size, location and other factors including no engineering department, etc.

SAT/ACT test result submission is rapidly declining at both, but they are pretty much equal in the percentage that still do.

In my personal view, purely looking at admission % and caliber. Yes, UVA has a lower admission rate, but the caliber of kids getting into either is pretty much equal.

Let you kid decide which one is the better fit/offer for them. Visiting both, they should have a clear preference.

Yep. The caliber is the same and been the same for decades. The number of out-of-caliber students applying is higher for UVA. And going to my friends graduation - both camps seem to graduate with the look of a battered wife. No idea what kind of program humbles a 4.0+ kid. On that note - the VA Tech kids seem to run out of graduation like Vikings in spring time. The GMU kids look like nothing's changed - its part of life Man!

Are you saying UVA and W&M grads don't appear to have enjoyed their experience while VT grads did? That isn't my perception.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:W&M parent here. Why do we have to go over this every couple months again and again?

Yes, UVA has a lower acceptance rate as it offers engineering and bigger sports, etc. which W&M does not. So, it appeals to a larger group of prospective students. No hard feelings, why would there be? (at least not from me).

W&M has always been a bit more self-selecting due to its size, location and other factors including no engineering department, etc.

SAT/ACT test result submission is rapidly declining at both, but they are pretty much equal in the percentage that still do.

In my personal view, purely looking at admission % and caliber. Yes, UVA has a lower admission rate, but the caliber of kids getting into either is pretty much equal.

Let you kid decide which one is the better fit/offer for them. Visiting both, they should have a clear preference.

Yep. The caliber is the same and been the same for decades. The number of out-of-caliber students applying is higher for UVA. And going to my friends graduation - both camps seem to graduate with the look of a battered wife. No idea what kind of program humbles a 4.0+ kid. On that note - the VA Tech kids seem to run out of graduation like Vikings in spring time. The GMU kids look like nothing's changed - its part of life Man!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:W&M parent here. Why do we have to go over this every couple months again and again?

Yes, UVA has a lower acceptance rate as it offers engineering and bigger sports, etc. which W&M does not. So, it appeals to a larger group of prospective students. No hard feelings, why would there be? (at least not from me).

W&M has always been a bit more self-selecting due to its size, location and other factors including no engineering department, etc.

SAT/ACT test result submission is rapidly declining at both, but they are pretty much equal in the percentage that still do.

In my personal view, purely looking at admission % and caliber. Yes, UVA has a lower admission rate, but the caliber of kids getting into either is pretty much equal.

Let you kid decide which one is the better fit/offer for them. Visiting both, they should have a clear preference.

Yep. The caliber is the same and been the same for decades. The number of out-of-caliber students applying is higher for UVA. And going to my friends graduation - both camps seem to graduate with the look of a battered wife. No idea what kind of program humbles a 4.0+ kid. On that note - the VA Tech kids seem to run out of graduation like Vikings in spring time. The GMU kids look like nothing's changed - its part of life Man!