My almost 8 year old has asked to be left home before, but we never had a chance to try it out. Because of this thread I asked her yesterday what she would do if someone came to the door, if there was a fire, etc. She answered everything mostly correctly, but then later she brought it back up and said she did not want to be left alone for "another few years." I think the questions made her think about it more tangibly and she got nervous. So if OP is still reading, maybe take that as a cautionary tale. She may like the idea as a hypothetical, but could get freaked out when confronted with the reality.