Anonymous wrote:We had a tour guide at a t10 college who said she ran track or maybe it was cross country for a year at the college. Then quit. She made it sound like the sport was fighting in a bloody war and she had to quit. It was so over the top. Congrats on scheming into the t10 as a student-athlete sweetie.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The fact is some of these elite athletes are training upwards of 15-20 hours per week. Pershing a passion- and if they can maintain a high GPA with a rigorous course load, why shouldn’t they get a boost. A highly skilled musician would also get the same consideration.
+1 people have no idea how much time it takes to be good enough to play in college. 20 hours is the minimum
It takes $$$$$$$$ to which a lot of people like to conveniently ignore. You can be an awesome field hockey player or swimmer, but if your parents are unwilling or unable to pay thousands of dollars per year in club fees, travel, equipment and uniforms, you aren’t getting recruited. It’s FAR from a meritocracy!
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:To get into a college you wouldn’t have gotten into otherwise, although in that case, you can quit the day you arrive on campus for freshmen year with no repercussions.
VERY very few families look at this way. I’d say probably <1% of families are savvy gunners using it to get into a super selective college. Majority just want to brag their kid “plays at the next level” and will go to crappy colleges they’d never otherwise consider to make it happen. Dumb as hell.
Where I live, 99% of the parents I know are indeed focusing on their kids’ sports as a way to get an admissions boost at highly selective, elite colleges or Universities. The same is true in every other wealthy, highly educated area in the country.
Well this is only gonna work if the kid does some ridiculous niche sport . I hope they realize this
Lacrosse, crew, field hockey
These sports are becoming really popular across the country, so it's competitive. Also, a lot of field hockey players at elite schools seem to be from overseas, which was surprising to me.
Field hockey is very competitive. And, part of that is that, yes, the really competitive programs (and even some of the not, now) are pulling international players. Yes, you CAN get a boost for admissions. But it's becoming more difficult. And the scholarship money isn't really there like it is for other sports. Our Club Director had a recruiting session (She was a D1 player at a big program) and I think the number she gave for D1 recruitment (and thus $$$) was 1-3% ranges. D3 offers not athletic money.
Looks like 10 percent of high school field hockey players compete in colleges
https://www.varsityedge.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/2016-02-26-13.16.57-1268x1500.jpg" border="0" class="embeddedImage" />
Trying again…
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The fact is some of these elite athletes are training upwards of 15-20 hours per week. Pershing a passion- and if they can maintain a high GPA with a rigorous course load, why shouldn’t they get a boost. A highly skilled musician would also get the same consideration.
+1 people have no idea how much time it takes to be good enough to play in college. 20 hours is the minimum
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The fact is some of these elite athletes are training upwards of 15-20 hours per week. Pershing a passion- and if they can maintain a high GPA with a rigorous course load, why shouldn’t they get a boost. A highly skilled musician would also get the same consideration.
+1 people have no idea how much time it takes to be good enough to play in college. 20 hours is the minimum
Anonymous wrote:The fact is some of these elite athletes are training upwards of 15-20 hours per week. Pershing a passion- and if they can maintain a high GPA with a rigorous course load, why shouldn’t they get a boost. A highly skilled musician would also get the same consideration.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Having not been a college athlete myself, I would say:
--Admissions boost to somewhere they wouldn't otherwise go
--Fun/enjoy the game/part of their identity/difficult to see that ending after HS
--Scholarship money at schools who give it
--Wasn't planning on a particularly difficult major anyway, so can put time into the sport
--Like the competition/travel
--Some are legit thinking they may be able to "go pro," and some are right
Admissions boost applies to maybe <1% of student-athletes who go play at some place more selective than they would have otherwise gotten into.
Athletic scholarships also apply to maybe <1% of student-athletes who go D1.
Do you have stats on this? Doubt it. Do you think a lot of athletes at elite universities would have gotten in without the "hook" that athletics provided? Check out some scattergrams.
D1 aren't the only schools that give athletic scholarships. NAIA, e.g.
It’s simple math. There are what, 20, elite colleges you think you need this hook to get into? Add up the roster spots for the sport your snowflake plays x 20. Then subtract all the URMs, legacies and trust funders and you have the ACTUAL roster spots available for random recruited student-athletes. Then take that number and divide it by all the kids in the same graduating class who play said sport. <1% was being generous.
And as for D1, if you’re good enough to play D1 (highly, highly unlikely), there are a lot of mediocre D1 universities and they certainly do not give scholarships to all student-athletes. So, what’s even the point?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:To get into a college you wouldn’t have gotten into otherwise, although in that case, you can quit the day you arrive on campus for freshmen year with no repercussions.
VERY very few families look at this way. I’d say probably <1% of families are savvy gunners using it to get into a super selective college. Majority just want to brag their kid “plays at the next level” and will go to crappy colleges they’d never otherwise consider to make it happen. Dumb as hell.
Where I live, 99% of the parents I know are indeed focusing on their kids’ sports as a way to get an admissions boost at highly selective, elite colleges or Universities. The same is true in every other wealthy, highly educated area in the country.
Well this is only gonna work if the kid does some ridiculous niche sport . I hope they realize this
Lacrosse, crew, field hockey
These sports are becoming really popular across the country, so it's competitive. Also, a lot of field hockey players at elite schools seem to be from overseas, which was surprising to me.
Field hockey is very competitive. And, part of that is that, yes, the really competitive programs (and even some of the not, now) are pulling international players. Yes, you CAN get a boost for admissions. But it's becoming more difficult. And the scholarship money isn't really there like it is for other sports. Our Club Director had a recruiting session (She was a D1 player at a big program) and I think the number she gave for D1 recruitment (and thus $$$) was 1-3% ranges. D3 offers not athletic money.
Looks like 10 percent of high school field hockey players compete in colleges
https://www.varsityedge.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/2016-02-26-13.16.57-1268x1500.jpg" border="0" class="embeddedImage" />
Anonymous wrote:I work with many colleagues with HS and college aged kids (some URMs) who are athletes of varied sports. My colleagues’ athletic kids are most definitely getting preferential admission over their classmates with “better” GPAs and higher test scores, at least to top state schools like UVA, UCLA and UNC (including the kids who are not recruited athletes or chose not to play).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:To get into a college you wouldn’t have gotten into otherwise, although in that case, you can quit the day you arrive on campus for freshmen year with no repercussions.
VERY very few families look at this way. I’d say probably <1% of families are savvy gunners using it to get into a super selective college. Majority just want to brag their kid “plays at the next level” and will go to crappy colleges they’d never otherwise consider to make it happen. Dumb as hell.
Where I live, 99% of the parents I know are indeed focusing on their kids’ sports as a way to get an admissions boost at highly selective, elite colleges or Universities. The same is true in every other wealthy, highly educated area in the country.
Well this is only gonna work if the kid does some ridiculous niche sport . I hope they realize this
Lacrosse, crew, field hockey
These sports are becoming really popular across the country, so it's competitive. Also, a lot of field hockey players at elite schools seem to be from overseas, which was surprising to me.
Field hockey is very competitive. And, part of that is that, yes, the really competitive programs (and even some of the not, now) are pulling international players. Yes, you CAN get a boost for admissions. But it's becoming more difficult. And the scholarship money isn't really there like it is for other sports. Our Club Director had a recruiting session (She was a D1 player at a big program) and I think the number she gave for D1 recruitment (and thus $$$) was 1-3% ranges. D3 offers not athletic money.
Looks like 10 percent of high school field hockey players compete in colleges
https://www.varsityedge.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/2016-02-26-13.16.57-1268x1500.jpg" border="0" class="embeddedImage" />

Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:To get into a college you wouldn’t have gotten into otherwise, although in that case, you can quit the day you arrive on campus for freshmen year with no repercussions.
VERY very few families look at this way. I’d say probably <1% of families are savvy gunners using it to get into a super selective college. Majority just want to brag their kid “plays at the next level” and will go to crappy colleges they’d never otherwise consider to make it happen. Dumb as hell.
Where I live, 99% of the parents I know are indeed focusing on their kids’ sports as a way to get an admissions boost at highly selective, elite colleges or Universities. The same is true in every other wealthy, highly educated area in the country.
Well this is only gonna work if the kid does some ridiculous niche sport . I hope they realize this
Lacrosse, crew, field hockey
These sports are becoming really popular across the country, so it's competitive. Also, a lot of field hockey players at elite schools seem to be from overseas, which was surprising to me.
Field hockey is very competitive. And, part of that is that, yes, the really competitive programs (and even some of the not, now) are pulling international players. Yes, you CAN get a boost for admissions. But it's becoming more difficult. And the scholarship money isn't really there like it is for other sports. Our Club Director had a recruiting session (She was a D1 player at a big program) and I think the number she gave for D1 recruitment (and thus $$$) was 1-3% ranges. D3 offers not athletic money.
Looks like 10 percent of high school field hockey players compete in colleges