I like both names. I think Eliza is a little classier, Scarlett is a little more fun.

I don't love your middle names for either, though. They're fine but super predictable and the combos you suggest double down on the issue with each name. Eliza Jane seems really trite and boring, and Scarlett Grace makes Scarlett seems a little more southern-fried. The one-syllable middle is kind of tired.

I would do Eliza Claire (I think I like this the most) or Scarlett Claire, or Scarlett Eliza.

Both are pretty, but I prefer Scarlett, as it strikes me as slightly less frequently used.

Eliza.

Scarlett is so overused and has always sounded harsh and kind of low class to me.

Eliza Claire or Eliza Grace.

Anonymous wrote:There's an old song about Oh, Eliza! Little Liza Jane! Nevertheless, I like it a lot better than Scarlett.

My thoughts exactly. Scarlett permanently ruined by GWTW

I don't care for Scarlett at all, but Eliza is fine.

I feel like a Scarlett has to have red hair.

I love Scarlett. It’s always been my favorite girl name.

Scarlett is becoming overused. We already know 2. I’d say go with Eliza.

Anonymous wrote:Eliza J is a clothing brand.

I like Claire more

Claire is literally a name of a tween retail store.

Scarlett is a little too “dance moms” for me!
Eliza is classic and pretty- not overly common.

Eliza J is a clothing brand.

I like Claire more

Anonymous wrote:DH wants one and I like the other. Picking a name for this child has been absolute hell and I'd prefer not to start over again.



If we go with Eliza her middle name will be Claire or Jane.


Scarlett middle names are Anne or Grace.

Eliza is ugly to me. It's the Z.

Scarlett, like, Scarlett letter?

Claire is so much better. Go with that.

Scarlett Doolittle or Eliza O'Hara.

Scarlett I think of Gone With the Wind.
Eliza Jane, I think of the song, Little Liza Jane.

Eliza is fine, but don’t use Scarlett.