Brio trains

Duplos
Geotrax, don't know if they still make those.

Magnatiles
Scooter
Animal figurines
Play kitchen
Sprinkler

Agree this age is pretty easy to please. And agree that cicadas are the best toy of all.

Duplos and Brio/other wooden trains are always a hit.

Art supplies, her scooter, sidewalk chalk, toy kitchen, kapla blocks, and water table are current favorites.

dress up clothes
We have about 30 costumes mostly from amazon, capes, swords, doctor kits, vet kit, police officer, fire man

A lite bright!! A throw back toy, but DD is obsessed with it.

My four year old got a “bug viewer” for her birthday and it’s pretty cool. She’s only sort of into it (her friends are more into it). She loves the game “Spot it”. Her favorite toy (carries everywhere, twirls, drums with it, and would sleep with it if we didn’t stop her) is a handle from an old push toy that she refers to as “Drum stick”. I think a set of actual drum sticks would go over well. My older DD liked getting a set of Pom poms at this age. My older DD loved her play dollhouse at this age, the younger one is more into wooden train tracks (some) and magnatiles (a lot). Play tents and tunnels have also been a hit at a variety of ages.