Anonymous
04/11/2021 19:22
Subject: Stop. The. Screaming.
Duct tape.
Anonymous
04/11/2021 19:20
Subject: Stop. The. Screaming.
Anonymous wrote:Been there, still doing that. Youngest of three is 5. Still can't handle it if someone gets out of the car before him, freaks out if anyone laughs at him or looks at him the wrong way, or any time he feels like he's coming in last. I'm wondering when it gets better since 5 isn't it.
Same here. My 5 year old is a screamer and whiner. His two older siblings are so chill and DH and I never raise our voices. He took after my Italian grandmother, legend says you could hear her screaming at my mom in Brooklyn from New Jersey.
Anonymous
04/11/2021 19:17
Subject: Stop. The. Screaming.
I just need to chime in and say please don’t leave her in a room by herself. As previous poster said, she probably needs more attention not less. My son is a screamer and it peaked at 3. He’s 4 now and is so much better. I think it is mostly from maturing but we made a huge effort to give him positive praise whenever he asked for something and used words in a normal voice.
Anonymous
04/10/2021 10:23
Subject: Re:Stop. The. Screaming.
Anonymous wrote:She’s the third kid? Yup, seems about right.
She’s screaming because she needs and wants attention and it’s hard to get in a family of five. Full stop. Unlike your older children, she lacks the communication skills, or the self awareness, to get that attention in other ways. She is also starting from a deficit they didn’t have— there was more of you to go around when they were her age, so they likely developed a greater sense of security in you. Your third kid doesn’t have that.
The only way to change the behavior is the find a way to get her the sense of security. That’s going to mean being proactive about 1:1 time, giving her focused attention during family activities, etc. You might think you give her this already, because you are thinking of how her screaming and tantrums derails family activity and how much energy goes into dealing with them. But that attentions isn’t fun for anyone, including her.
Try: during family meals, give everyone a chance to talk about their day. Including her. I know, she will not really understand the question and won’t know how to answer at first. That’s fine, she’s two. But show her the same interest you would show in her older siblings and she’ll catch in quicker than you think. And make sure her older siblings are also listening to her. This will be hard for them at first. Everyone practice. These are good skills.
Also set aside time every day where she gets 1:1 time with a parent. It can be 15 minutes. But make it special, allow her to choose the activity, and do it every day.
All of this is more important than how you deal with the screaming directly.
This is a good post.
Anonymous
04/10/2021 10:11
Subject: Re:Stop. The. Screaming.
She’s the third kid? Yup, seems about right.
She’s screaming because she needs and wants attention and it’s hard to get in a family of five. Full stop. Unlike your older children, she lacks the communication skills, or the self awareness, to get that attention in other ways. She is also starting from a deficit they didn’t have— there was more of you to go around when they were her age, so they likely developed a greater sense of security in you. Your third kid doesn’t have that.
The only way to change the behavior is the find a way to get her the sense of security. That’s going to mean being proactive about 1:1 time, giving her focused attention during family activities, etc. You might think you give her this already, because you are thinking of how her screaming and tantrums derails family activity and how much energy goes into dealing with them. But that attentions isn’t fun for anyone, including her.
Try: during family meals, give everyone a chance to talk about their day. Including her. I know, she will not really understand the question and won’t know how to answer at first. That’s fine, she’s two. But show her the same interest you would show in her older siblings and she’ll catch in quicker than you think. And make sure her older siblings are also listening to her. This will be hard for them at first. Everyone practice. These are good skills.
Also set aside time every day where she gets 1:1 time with a parent. It can be 15 minutes. But make it special, allow her to choose the activity, and do it every day.
All of this is more important than how you deal with the screaming directly.
She’s screaming because she needs and wants attention and it’s hard to get in a family of five. Full stop. Unlike your older children, she lacks the communication skills, or the self awareness, to get that attention in other ways. She is also starting from a deficit they didn’t have— there was more of you to go around when they were her age, so they likely developed a greater sense of security in you. Your third kid doesn’t have that.
The only way to change the behavior is the find a way to get her the sense of security. That’s going to mean being proactive about 1:1 time, giving her focused attention during family activities, etc. You might think you give her this already, because you are thinking of how her screaming and tantrums derails family activity and how much energy goes into dealing with them. But that attentions isn’t fun for anyone, including her.
Try: during family meals, give everyone a chance to talk about their day. Including her. I know, she will not really understand the question and won’t know how to answer at first. That’s fine, she’s two. But show her the same interest you would show in her older siblings and she’ll catch in quicker than you think. And make sure her older siblings are also listening to her. This will be hard for them at first. Everyone practice. These are good skills.
Also set aside time every day where she gets 1:1 time with a parent. It can be 15 minutes. But make it special, allow her to choose the activity, and do it every day.
All of this is more important than how you deal with the screaming directly.
Anonymous
04/10/2021 10:04
Subject: Re:Stop. The. Screaming.
Anonymous wrote:You might try these: When she is in a good mood, ask her why she screams. Tell her there are other ways to get her point across than screaming. It is really hard to be the youngest of three - she probably feels like she doesn't have much control in the house, everyone talks over her, leaves her behind, ignores her and screaming is her way of communicating over the noise.
If that doesn't work, the next time she does it, do it with her. I used to throw myself on the floor next to my tantrum throwing child and throw one with her. It threw her off completely and we ended up laughing about it.
Finally, what my other friend did was video tape it. And show her later.
But this is all about being heard and having some control.
The neighbors kid was running down the block last summer arms flailing in the air screaming her head off. I turned to my husband and said it is soooooo tempting to join her right now!