Op here: okay I got her some fancy feast and mixed it with her regular food 1/2 and 1/2 and she gobbles it up like it’s crack. Is it really not good for her? Why? She’s also 8 months old and her dry food and old food is for kittens, fancy feast is not. It might be the texture, the fancy feast is small chunks in some kind of liquid. Her fancy wellness grain free expensive stuff she rejected is like a thick pate. She does seem to like her dry food but doesn’t eat a ton of it.

If she barely touches it, she definitely doesn’t like it because cats are greedy AF.

Cat’s pickiness with food decreases proportionally as the time since their last meal increases.

A cat that turned her nose up yesterday and didn’t eat will be happy to scarf down the same exact food 24 hours later.