Anonymous wrote:I'm a South Florida girl who deals with homesickness by making too many key lime pies. The best recipe is the simplest but don't waste time juicing the limes, just be sure to buy Nellie and Joe's (it's by the real lemon in most grocery stores). https://keylimejuice.com/nellie-joes-key-lime-pie/
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
Same. I just love hers. Key Lime is my fave.
Any recipe that suggests using "regular" limes is not authentic. There is a very distinct difference in the taste of Key limes and regular limes.
-- signed, a Floridian who has been making KL pies for decades
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I cheated on Key Lime Pie with Turtle Pie in California. Np going back,,,![]()
Turtle Pie is so good ... May be better then average sex.![]()
![]()
Smooth caramel filling infused with rich caramel, topped with chocolate, pecans, and whipped crème rosettes on a fresh-from-the-oven chocolate cookie crumb crust.
BTW.. do not confuse Turtle pie with the horrible frozen boxed desert at your local supermarket. You have to make it at home or go to CA to try it there, they know how to make it.
Anonymous wrote:OP. you need to EARN a pie on Pi day!
How many digits can you remember?
![]()

Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I cheated on Key Lime Pie with Turtle Pie in California. Np going back,,,![]()
Turtle Pie is so good ... May be better then average sex.![]()
![]()
Smooth caramel filling infused with rich caramel, topped with chocolate, pecans, and whipped crème rosettes on a fresh-from-the-oven chocolate cookie crumb crust.
BTW.. do not confuse Turtle pie with the horrible frozen boxed desert at your local supermarket. You have to make it at home or go to CA to try it there, they know how to make it.
I love Baskin Robbins turtle pie