Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Should be per household. Penalizes single parents who get $0 while making the same income as a childless married couple or family with one earner making the same or more. In both situations there is just one earner. How does that make sense?

Yes this makes no sense to me - I’m HOH with 2 dependents and make $160k. I get nothing but my friend who is a SAH and whose husband makes $160 will receive $3400

I am sorry. I find that maddening.

+1

Maybe people will donate within networks of family and friends. We aren’t getting it either, but actually do need it because of out of pocket medical expenses for my father and wages lost in early 2020 getting him into a nursing facility.

Anonymous wrote:That may answer a lot of questions people have if they qualify.

FWIW, I confirmed we will not and I am fine with that we are a two fed family with secure jobs that can be done remotely. I thank that is correct.

Thank you. Don’t worry that there wasn’t a link. It was easy to find.

We are getting $3500. We don't need it. I will be donating it to my sister who just got laid off.

So parents get $500 per kid 17 and under
College students are are declared as dependents by their parents, do not get the stimulus even if they have filed with income, but their parents do not get extra stimulus for them.

Anonymous wrote:

Should be per household. Penalizes single parents who get $0 while making the same income as a childless married couple or family with one earner making the same or more. In both situations there is just one earner. How does that make sense?

Yes this makes no sense to me - I’m HOH with 2 dependents and make $160k. I get nothing but my friend who is a SAH and whose husband makes $160 will receive $3400

I am sorry. I find that maddening.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Spouse is responsible for taxes on her MFJ return. Spouse is responsible for tax on interest earned. MFJ is a designation where two incomes (whatever the source) become one for tax purposes. There are benefits and potential penalties to filing jointly. It's not your problem or business how much your friend receives.

+1

This is 1200 per human. It’s not 2400 per household.

But it’s not, because you don’t get $1200 as a person above a certain income level while someone else at the same income level does.

Anonymous wrote:I don't get it. ~$200K AIG HHI for 2018 with one child. Just for fun I put that into the calculator... and I'm getting $300? Why? I thought I'd get nothing. Anyone know?

Your kid. It changes the scale at which the stimulus decreases to zero.

it's a 5% phase out of income over $150k (if married).

So if you are married with one child your potential full amount is $1,200 * 2 + $500 * 1 = $2,900.
Then if your AGI is 200K, that is 50K over the phase out (200k - 150k). 50k * 0.05 = $2,500. Your potential credit is reduced by this amount.

$2,900 - $2,500 = $400 remaining credit you will get.

I don't get it. ~$200K AIG HHI for 2018 with one child. Just for fun I put that into the calculator... and I'm getting $300? Why? I thought I'd get nothing. Anyone know?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Spouse is responsible for taxes on her MFJ return. Spouse is responsible for tax on interest earned. MFJ is a designation where two incomes (whatever the source) become one for tax purposes. There are benefits and potential penalties to filing jointly. It's not your problem or business how much your friend receives.

+1

This is 1200 per human. It’s not 2400 per household.

+1
they are getting more than the HoH person because they also have A WHOLE NOTHING ADULT to feed, cloth and shelter.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Spouse is responsible for taxes on her MFJ return. Spouse is responsible for tax on interest earned. MFJ is a designation where two incomes (whatever the source) become one for tax purposes. There are benefits and potential penalties to filing jointly. It's not your problem or business how much your friend receives.

+1

This is 1200 per human. It’s not 2400 per household.

Yes, what's a "household" anyway? Government really doesn't need to be in the business of analyzing people's relationships and if they're roommates or a "household". Per human being is what makes sense.

Chalk it up against the marriage penalty.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Spouse is responsible for taxes on her MFJ return. Spouse is responsible for tax on interest earned. MFJ is a designation where two incomes (whatever the source) become one for tax purposes. There are benefits and potential penalties to filing jointly. It's not your problem or business how much your friend receives.

+1

This is 1200 per human. It’s not 2400 per household.

Anonymous wrote:^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Spouse is responsible for taxes on her MFJ return. Spouse is responsible for tax on interest earned. MFJ is a designation where two incomes (whatever the source) become one for tax purposes. There are benefits and potential penalties to filing jointly. It's not your problem or business how much your friend receives.

^^
$1200 for spouse making $160k
$1200 for SAH spouse making $0
$1000 for 2 kids

Should be per household. Penalizes single parents who get $0 while making the same income as a childless married couple or family with one earner making the same or more. In both situations there is just one earner. How does that make sense?

Yes this makes no sense to me - I’m HOH with 2 dependents and make $160k. I get nothing but my friend who is a SAH and whose husband makes $160 will receive $3400