Anonymous wrote:I really think it’s Don. I think Jay is guilty of something and the police used that to use as motivation for him to deliver the suspect.

Agree. Even if Adnan is guilty they never should have gotten a conviction with such shoddy evidence.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:But if he’s innocent, there’s no optics for a stranger nor Jay or Jen to kill her.

I also find it strange that he so freely shared his phone and car with someone he said he was not close to.

If not Adnan, Don is the most likely culprit. Then Jay.

I think Jay is most likely. He had a criminal background, a rivalry with Adnan, has changed his story several times, and has gone on to commit violence against women.

Anonymous wrote:But if he’s innocent, there’s no optics for a stranger nor Jay or Jen to kill her.

I also find it strange that he so freely shared his phone and car with someone he said he was not close to.

If not Adnan, Don is the most likely culprit. Then Jay.

Innocent

But if he’s innocent, there’s no optics for a stranger nor Jay or Jen to kill her.

I also find it strange that he so freely shared his phone and car with someone he said he was not close to.

He's innocent. I mean even from a statistical likelihood standpoint... a magnant student, football player, prom king randomly killing his exgf, who he got along with, one day after school, and then going back to football practice like an hour later? I mean the story is nutty and the villain a little too sparkly clean.

Innocent.

I really think it’s Don. I think Jay is guilty of something and the police used that to use as motivation for him to deliver the suspect.

Guilty. And I think jay was more involved than what he admitted to.

I’m leading toward innocent.

I think probably guilty but definitely not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. That is a high burden to meet and I don’t think the evidence is close to that.

Anonymous wrote:I don't know. 60/40 guilty, I think.

That said, he's served decades in prison. He's done his time for a crime he may or may not have committed. He deserves to be released.

This, add that the original verdict was based on falsified evidence and should be overturned.

Anonymous wrote:Innocent - I know someone involved in the case.

The police interview with Jay was a mess.

True. But Adnan could still be guilty.

Any other details to add?

I don't know. 60/40 guilty, I think.

That said, he's served decades in prison. He's done his time for a crime he may or may not have committed. He deserves to be released.

Innocent.