Anonymous wrote:My rule of thumb here is to just lop off a hundred thousand from whatever folks say is in their 401k. It’s like a monetary anonymous d*** measuring contest. As an aside, the same goes for self reported commute times. No ma’am, you’re not getting from Leesnurg to Farragut West in 20 minutes, “tops”.
This makes me laugh, but for myself I'm honest (I round up/down for ease but not to distort). Whenever there's something like this I feel like responding to, I just open the excel sheet where I keep the numbers and put what they ask for. Our income numbers are usually lower than the average reported but we've done just fine so I feel maybe that might reassure a fellow moderate lurker who starts to think you can't live here/ever retire/have a regular middle class life without 200k HHI minimum. I assume there's some who lie--or who have optimistic ways of measuring money/commutes/children's intelligence --but I would think that's probably 15-20% of folks. If you lie, you probably think everybody else is lying, so why would you bother reading/asking--there would be too low signal/noise? But I'm female, so maybe I'm less attuned to d*** measuring contests?
The rounding might be relative too. My teenage kids count their assets to the penny, but I'll round up/down to the nearest 25 or 50K if talking about assets and the nearest 10K if talking about income. Someone who makes/has a lot more may round up/down by 100K, quarter, half million etc. for assets and 50k by income.