Anonymous
04/01/2018 22:20
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
So kids are in the pool based on both test scores can get rejected?
PP. It happened last year, at least if memory serves. I'm not sure if those kids got in on appeal.
I wonder why they didn't make it first round. I would think low GBRS? I mean how low can it be to reject those kids?
PP again, the one who paid more attention last year. I tried to find last year's thread re: this and I'm not having much luck :/. I would suspect it had to do with low-ish grades on report cards and/or low GBRS. I do remember someone posting that 2/3 of kids who are in-pool based on scores were accepted in past years, and that seemed weird to me. Again, though, I would think a kid with in-pool scores who got rejected would have a good shot at acceptance with an appeal, as long as their report cards weren't horrible.
Anonymous
04/01/2018 22:04
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
So kids are in the pool based on both test scores can get rejected?
PP. It happened last year, at least if memory serves. I'm not sure if those kids got in on appeal.
I wonder why they didn't make it first round. I would think low GBRS? I mean how low can it be to reject those kids?
Anonymous
04/01/2018 22:03
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
I wonder why they didn't make it first round. I would think low GBRS? I mean how low can it be to reject those kids?
So kids are in the pool based on both test scores can get rejected?
PP. It happened last year, at least if memory serves. I'm not sure if those kids got in on appeal.
Anonymous
04/01/2018 21:47
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
So kids are in the pool based on both test scores can get rejected?
PP. It happened last year, at least if memory serves. I'm not sure if those kids got in on appeal.
Anonymous
04/01/2018 21:20
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
So kids are in the pool based on both test scores can get rejected?
Anonymous
04/01/2018 21:16
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
NP. My kid was in second grade last year so I paid a bit more attention when people were posting scores, but there were more than a few kids with scores above the cutoff who didn't get in first round. I have no idea if it was a weird year or what, but several well-versed posters last year were really baffled at some of the rejected (and accepted) scores.
Anonymous
04/01/2018 20:31
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
I'm curious - On this board, we don't really talk about kids with above cut off score on both NNAT and COGAT too often. Anyone had to do an appeals or didn't make it at all?
Anonymous
04/01/2018 09:51
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
My child has similar scores, slightly above cut off. But I don’t know gbrs either. If gbrs is not too high, what’s my chance?
Anonymous
03/30/2018 22:44
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
My guess is no first round for my kid. I have a WISC already scheduled. GBRS 13. I won’t post the CoGAT scores Bc they are low and I can’t take the naysayers.
Anonymous
03/30/2018 22:02
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
Hope your DC get in. These are very good scores.
Thank you. I see some posts on this board about scores in high 130s and 140s and I wasn't sure if these scores would be good enough for me to relax. Also concerned about GBRS because I don't get a good vibe from teacher/AART and didn't get any feedback.
Anonymous
03/30/2018 21:58
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
Hope your DC get in. These are very good scores.
Anonymous
03/30/2018 21:47
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Chances?
Anonymous
03/30/2018 21:47
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
NNAT 135 COGAT 134 GBRS unknown.
Changes?
Changes?
Anonymous
03/30/2018 21:36
Subject: Re:Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:135 NNAT 126 coGat 13 GBRS chances of getting in the first round?
I would say yes.
Anonymous
03/30/2018 14:17
Subject: Chances? Your guesses?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Chance me:
- 123 Cogat,
- 13 GBRS with an identified Math strength,
- IEP for dyslexia, dysgraphia and ADHD,
- inconclusive WISC (yup - both GAI and FSIQ have too much variation to draw a conclusion) but with a 99.percentile VSI.
- not in 2nd Grade, principal requested us to refer.
Apologies - that should read 99.5 percentile VCI (Verbal Comprehension Index) not VSI!
If this is too personal you don't have to answer, but do you mind me asking what the point difference was between the GAI and FSIQ? I am new to all this and have never heard of that before.
The issue was not the variation between FSIQ and GAI, it was that there was significant difference amoung the subtest scores that make up BOTH the GAI and FSIQ of more than 5 points. So, for example, within a single Index, scores varied from 21percentile to ninety one percentile. The tester this felt that neither FSIQ of GAI was an adequate measure of intellectual ability.
Neuropsychologist here - 5 points is NOT a significant variation. You will have strengths and weaknesses within the subtests. Variations over 2 SD is significant.
I thought that was her point? BTW, I've never heard of an inconclusive WISC! So you have no IQ score? So confused.