I think the staying power sucks for the price.

I'm liking the Commodity line now. Really offbeat stuff to mix and match.

I like Grapefruit for summer and Bergamot and Cucumber year round. A lot of them are too sweet for me. The bergamot dries down to a very faint smell

Another vote for French Lime Blossom

I think They are so subtle...I use a little bit and the scent smells really soft and subtle on me...maybe it depends on your body chemistry or something?? I hate overpowering perfume and I love jo Malone

It's so funny a lot of people don't like them; they are the only perfumes I love!!

OP here. Thanks for all of the responses. I received a Suede Blush and Peonies sample before and thought it was too floral for me, but I actually mixed it with the Wood Sage this past weekend and received lots of compliments. I may have to get it for mixing. I will go and check out some of their new scents.

Oprah had her stuff on a favourites list a few years ago and I made it a point to smell them.

OMG they are so heavy smelling, I really do believe they can only be used as air fresheners. I wouldn't want to go around smelling like those strong smells.

Do people actually wear it on their body? How do you tone it down?

Ooh, some of the new ones look interesting like the Nashi blossom or the Strawberry and parsley one. Will have to check out samples.