Have you tried to switch carriers? If you've been with State Farm for 25 years, then you are likely paying way too much. If you try to switch, I guarantee they will bring those accidents that weren't your fault up. They do count against you.
Doubt it. Why in the heck would you switch carriers if you are totally happy with the carrier you have?
We have been with USAA for 38 years and have had various accidents, mostly not our fault. Mostly fender benders, but one major. We have a young son on the policy (age 21) and 3 cars insured. Premiums are 2K per year in Fairfax County . . . I don't think that is exorbitant. And even if it's a couple of hundred more than somewhere else, it's worth it for the service we have always gotten from them.