Anonymous
Post 01/12/2016 06:33     Subject: Re:MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:So what is an acceptable conversation topic to discuss with parents? The weather, what you ate that day, ...? I generally agree that you should address your problems with the person with whom you have an issue, but sometimes you might need to test out how you address said issue with someone else first.


There is nothing wrong with that. The problem is most people have totally fucked relationships with their parents. And spouses, for that matter LOL
Anonymous
Post 01/12/2016 06:32     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:Better to tell him not to share, OP. It helps set the guidelines.

Better work on creating an environment where DH trusts OP enough to discuss their problems with her instead of somebody else.
Anonymous
Post 01/12/2016 01:19     Subject: Re:MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

So what is an acceptable conversation topic to discuss with parents? The weather, what you ate that day, ...? I generally agree that you should address your problems with the person with whom you have an issue, but sometimes you might need to test out how you address said issue with someone else first.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 23:29     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:Thanks - OP here. I don't have any real indicator that he's talked to her about anything recently. It came up a really long time ago about something pretty major. In the context of some troubles we were having, he told her I was pregnant even though we'd agreed not to tell anyone (I may have even posted about this here, I can't remember). About 1.5 years later he told me that, which is when I found out that he talks to her about marital stuff. I overreacted, and basically forbade him to do it going forward. That was all a year ago. We did have at least one conversation since where I softened my position on him talking to her... I think similar to what PP suggested, we agreed in principle that he wouldn't talk to her about something without telling me either before or shortly after. But really we haven't talked about this

Something happened this morning that I would really not want him sharing with her, so it just occurred to me to post, to see how reasonable that feeling was. I don't think I'm going to specifically bring it up with him, I don't have any real reason to think he's doing it.


I remember your post! I think when you finally did a pregnancy announcement to the family, she pretended to be surprised or something, and you found out that she already knew after the fact?

If you're the same person, your husband is completely out of line.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 18:29     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Better to tell him not to share, OP. It helps set the guidelines.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 17:38     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Thanks - OP here. I don't have any real indicator that he's talked to her about anything recently. It came up a really long time ago about something pretty major. In the context of some troubles we were having, he told her I was pregnant even though we'd agreed not to tell anyone (I may have even posted about this here, I can't remember). About 1.5 years later he told me that, which is when I found out that he talks to her about marital stuff. I overreacted, and basically forbade him to do it going forward. That was all a year ago. We did have at least one conversation since where I softened my position on him talking to her... I think similar to what PP suggested, we agreed in principle that he wouldn't talk to her about something without telling me either before or shortly after. But really we haven't talked about this

Something happened this morning that I would really not want him sharing with her, so it just occurred to me to post, to see how reasonable that feeling was. I don't think I'm going to specifically bring it up with him, I don't have any real reason to think he's doing it.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 14:23     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:I would be extremely unhappy about this situation. I don't tell my parents negative things about my spouse because first and foremost I am their child and they, regardless of how old I am, have my interests and my well-being at heart and would most definitely treat my husband differently if I discussed any relationship issues we might be having. I don't want that because I intend to stay married and don't want there to be a strained IL relationship.

My MIL and I already butt heads, she doesn't need any additional ammo to dislike me and make things worse.


+1. I don't tell my parents (or my sisters for that matter) about problems I have with my husband because I don't want to sour their relationship with DH. My DH is the same way, he doesn't complain to his parents about issues problems he has with me.

I don't think many parents can be impartial when it comes to their children. I can't imagine a mother not allowing information about someone hurting her child to taint their view of that person, even if it is her child's spouse. I think using your parent as your main or only confidant when it comes to your marriage is asking for your parent to end up hating your spouse.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 14:20     Subject: Re:MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:Actually, it doesn't really matter how we feel-- what does your DH say when you tell him it makes you uncomfortable? That probably says more about your relationship than his confiding in his mom, which may from his perspective be normal and not unkind. Have you told him it makes you feel awkward/sad and that you would like to be closer to his mom but worry that she knows all of your most private shortfalls and mistakes? (If that's what you feel.)


This. Tell him how you feel. Hear what he says. Maybe he doesn't actually talk about you that much. Maybe he doesn't share details but is just seeing general advice. Maybe he never thought it would bother you and now he'll be more careful. Maybe he doesn't give a shit and he tells his mom all your personal business and refuses to stop. Find out what that answer is.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 14:07     Subject: Re:MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

My DIL put an end to my son calling me 3 years ago. She thinks she whipped him good but what she doesn't know is he calls me from his work. I think he's afraid of her because she's jealous of everyone and she threatens to leave when she doesn't get her way and pitches a fit.

I recently told him he shouldn't call me anymore. His mother wife would be angry.

I feel sorry for him but he chose the witch so now he has to do as she says.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 14:00     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

How's the sex? I ask 'cause this seems to be a weird dynamic ...
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 13:58     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Is your MIL generally supportive of your marriage? If she is, then I think that it's fine for your husband to talk to her to get advice and feedback about marital issues, within certain boundaries (nothing about our sex life, nothing that includes confidential information about me that I shared with him). Sometimes you need an outside perspective. But that person must be someone who supports your marriage, and who isn't going to exploit this to insert a wedge between you or try to make your problems worse.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 13:16     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Anonymous wrote:It seems like MIL is the only one DH ever confides in about his problems. How would you feel about this, particularly when it's about me? It makes me uncomfortable and I don't think I will ever have any kind of warm relationship with MIL because of it.


Whoa. That is not ok, it is a huge boundary and trust violation.

If your DH doesn't understand this, then you need to get yourselves to couples counseling.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 13:08     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

I guess my reaction would depend on whether I felt MIL was likely to be fair, and generally is an ally/advocate for the marriage.

If she hates you, I would be pissed.
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 12:45     Subject: Re:MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

Actually, it doesn't really matter how we feel-- what does your DH say when you tell him it makes you uncomfortable? That probably says more about your relationship than his confiding in his mom, which may from his perspective be normal and not unkind. Have you told him it makes you feel awkward/sad and that you would like to be closer to his mom but worry that she knows all of your most private shortfalls and mistakes? (If that's what you feel.)
Anonymous
Post 01/11/2016 12:45     Subject: MIL as DH's confidante - how would you feel about this?

I would be extremely unhappy about this situation. I don't tell my parents negative things about my spouse because first and foremost I am their child and they, regardless of how old I am, have my interests and my well-being at heart and would most definitely treat my husband differently if I discussed any relationship issues we might be having. I don't want that because I intend to stay married and don't want there to be a strained IL relationship.

My MIL and I already butt heads, she doesn't need any additional ammo to dislike me and make things worse.