I'm the Casper poster who had to return a Costco mattress. The one I returned was the Pritchard Ultra Firm --it was wayyy too firm for me, and we woke up achy because of it. So I ended up getting a memory foam topper, which made it too squishy and hot to sleep; the combo wasn't for me. To each her own! I stand by my Casper. At least Costco has a fab return policy, and the current price is lower than what I paid.

Thanks everyone for the responses... Thinking I will just go online to Costco and order. Sitting in my office right now with an achy back b/c the bed it so bad.

We also have the Costco ultra firm as our main bed and LOVE it. Have another Costco mattress (all memory foam) as our guest bed.

After returning two mattresses and eating the shipping/restocking fees, we finally found the right one from Costco: Sealy Posturepedic Prichard Ultra Firm. Loved it, just ordered another one. There is a $150-$200 discount right now. So it is a great price.

After 7 years, we still love our westin heavenly bed.

Try Leesa.com

Anonymous wrote:We have the knock-off tempurpedic in a box from Costco for both our room and the guest room. I think the King is about $600. It is quite comfortable. We have not had it long enough to find out if it "tacos."

Oh, it does, trust me!

I got a Pure Bliss (latex) with a topper and love it. I tried the different versions locally and then ordered it from https://www.matt-to-go.com/Pure_Latex_Bliss.html as it was much cheaper.