Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

NP here. How can breastmilk not be vegan? If the mother is vegan (although I assume she is taking some supplements), then how can her breastmilk not be vegan? What is the logic?

Cows eat vegan. So then isn't cow's milk vegan?

Veganism doesn't mean "from mammal". Here is a definition from the https://www.vegansociety.com/try-vegan/definition-veganism

Veganism is a way of living which seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose.

A mother feeding her baby is not exploitative.

I agree that there is a profound difference between providing breast milk to a baby vs. drinking cow's milk. However the argument that a vegan mother produces vegan breast milk is quite silly. "Where's the logic" indeed?

Most vegans that I've known feed their young kids a less strict vegetarian diet. And nursed them as infants.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

NP here. How can breastmilk not be vegan? If the mother is vegan (although I assume she is taking some supplements), then how can her breastmilk not be vegan? What is the logic?

Cows are also vegans, but their milk isn't considered vegan.

I think that most vegans are fine with breastmilk, but that doesn't make breastmilk vegan, it just means that most vegans make an exception for breastmilk.

I think a vegan infant on breastmilk can thrive. I think that if a baby isn't able to breastfeed a vegan diet is not safe for an infant.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

NP here. How can breastmilk not be vegan? If the mother is vegan (although I assume she is taking some supplements), then how can her breastmilk not be vegan? What is the logic?

Cows eat vegan. So then isn't cow's milk vegan?

Veganism doesn't mean "from mammal". Here is a definition from the https://www.vegansociety.com/try-vegan/definition-veganism

Veganism is a way of living which seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose.

A mother feeding her baby is not exploitative.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

NP here. How can breastmilk not be vegan? If the mother is vegan (although I assume she is taking some supplements), then how can her breastmilk not be vegan? What is the logic?

Cows eat vegan. So then isn't cow's milk vegan?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

NP here. How can breastmilk not be vegan? If the mother is vegan (although I assume she is taking some supplements), then how can her breastmilk not be vegan? What is the logic?

Anonymous wrote:I was raised vegetarian and have many friends who were as well. We are all happy, healthy adults. Meat and eggs are not necessary for human health.

We see Dr. Fusner in Kensington and have had no issues around our diet. I've found the whole practice to be very supportive. I'm not sure if she's taking new patients though.

Good luck OP!

Good luck!

Dr. Fusner's practice has sent notice that the practice is closing, but there's rumor of the practice being bought. Be sure to ask appropriate questions.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Humans have the capacity to consent to the use of their milk. Breastmilk isn't comparable to other animal products.

I was raised vegetarian and have many friends who were as well. We are all happy, healthy adults. Meat and eggs are not necessary for human health.

We see Dr. Fusner in Kensington and have had no issues around our diet. I've found the whole practice to be very supportive. I'm not sure if she's taking new patients though.

Good luck OP!

Good luck!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is breastmilk vegan?

No. Breastmilk is NOT vegan and it has nothing to do with what the mother eats! Humans are mammals and breast milk is the milk from a mammal. That makes it absolutely NOT vegan.

Most vegans take issue with something coming from another animal like milk or an egg even if unfertilized.

Yes, humans are mammals, but most vegans wouldn't be opposed to animals feeding their own young.

It does not change the fact that human milk is NOT vegan.

Anonymous wrote:My guess is that a doctor from the Indian subcontinent will have experience with vegetarians as well as vegans. Jains are typically vegan.

My other guess would be a doctor in Takoma Park.

Jains aren't typically vegan as they take dairy.

Right, why would anyone feed their kids wholesome beans, nuts, fruits, legumes, fungi, grains, etc.?? Sounds like a nightmare! Someone call CPS and get that kid to McDonald's!!!

Yeah, because newborn babies are chowing down on all of that stuff.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why would you do that to a kid?

Right, why would anyone feed their kids wholesome beans, nuts, fruits, legumes, fungi, grains, etc.?? Sounds like a nightmare! Someone call CPS and get that kid to McDonald's!!!

We are talking about a baby here. I admire vegans for being conscious of the horrors of factory farming etc. BUT human babies weren't made to be vegan! I would go down this road when they're a little older. Just my two cents.

Human babies have lived over time in many environments and climates and are omnivores which means above all else they are ADAPTABLE to different diets. The only constant is that they need breastmilk in the beginning. Beyond that I think OP's baby will be just fine.

The vegan diet DOES NOT give humans everything they need to thrive. You are severely misguided if you think raising an infant vegan isn't child abuse.

I have an old friend who is vegan and even she makes sure her kids get dairy and eggs. Kids need rich proteins that plant material does not easily provide.

I'm pretty sure that vegan mothers would support breastfeeding - and probably extended breastfeeding at that. There are vegan families who raise healthy kids. The problem is that you have to be VERY careful balancing the diet or there will significant deficiencies causing malnutrition. There are websites and books that will show you how to do this but nuts and beans alone as the main proteins will not provide the nutrients that are easily accessed by eating meat, eggs, and dairy.

Would you be willing to give a dairy formula if baby was allergic tk soy and you didn't make enough milk?