Italians are conservative. But I doubt they hunt. Go to a Pirates baseball game. Or some other game with people from Pennsylvania. Or some other more conservative state.

Find a divorced fellow from Darien, CT.

...and I know you didn't specify politically conservative but you'll find there's a definite correlation between political conservatism and lifestyle conservatism.

Hey OP, I live in Midtown, voted for Romney and wear Sperrys and polo shirts and play tennis (and lots of other sports). I'm very, very un-metrosexual by NYC standards. Lets talk.