+1Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Are you people nuts? The kid is just at age 2. My son was having some issues with speech, spent a zillion dollars on therapy for a year. Stopped because it just seemed a waste. Now at age 4 he's fine. Believe me 2 is young. Unless there's dramatic issues - I mean obvious - a 2-6 month delay is not a big deal. My 2 yr old did not speak in phrases either. Now nearing 28 months she is beginning to do so. The other thing is to consider whether there are other languages spoken. The experts suggest it does not impact but my experience with my own kids and other bilingual families is it does.
When you're 2 years old, 6 months is a BIG DEAL. Also, please do not spread incorrect information--bilingualism does NOT cause speech delay.
I'm so glad you're kid caught up, but realize some of us start speech at 18 months or 2 years, and are still in speech years later because our children are delayed. You can't tell at 2, if a child will catch up in a few months or not so early intervention is essential.
Anonymous wrote:Are you people nuts? The kid is just at age 2. My son was having some issues with speech, spent a zillion dollars on therapy for a year. Stopped because it just seemed a waste. Now at age 4 he's fine. Believe me 2 is young. Unless there's dramatic issues - I mean obvious - a 2-6 month delay is not a big deal. My 2 yr old did not speak in phrases either. Now nearing 28 months she is beginning to do so. The other thing is to consider whether there are other languages spoken. The experts suggest it does not impact but my experience with my own kids and other bilingual families is it does.
Anonymous wrote:I actually had a phone consult with a speech therapist who said that if his receptive language is perfect, and if he has that many vocabulary words and no other delays (his motor skills etc. have always actually been ahead), he would never qualify for EI. not doing phrases at this age isnt technically behind. so question would be whether to pursue private speech therapy but I DOUBT he'd qualify for early intervention
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Have you tried modeling phrases for him or encouraging him to use them? My son was alot like that, but around he would come up to me and hand me a book and say "Read". And I'd respond, "who do you want to read the book?" When he said "mommy" I'd respond "Ok, can you say Mommy read?" DS caught on pretty quick, but I'm not sure when he would have done it if we hadn't started to insist a bit.
Bad advice. Trying to get your kid to repeat stuff is not effective. Read "It Takes Two To Talk". It's completely worth it (it's expensive) and very useful in working out ways to play/talk with your child that will encourage communication, But saying "can you say..." is not helpful. That said, he's not behind yet. Goal is to be combining words BY two. My oldest didn't until a few months after he turned two. He's an exceptionally smart kid (taught himself to read at three, for example), so I figure if he didn't combine until past 2, I won't worry about my younger kid (who is 22 months and not combining).
I'm sure there are different schools of thought. My son's speech therapy teacher DOES ask ds to say things. For example when she asks him to point to the dog in the book, and he points to the dog, she says "say 'there it is!'" or when he points to a box of cars and says "more cars" she says "can you say 'I want cars please!'" She's not necessarily looking for him to repeat word for word; she's trying to teach him to string more words together. If he doesn't respond she moves on and it's not the only technique she uses. PP, what does this book suggest?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Have you tried modeling phrases for him or encouraging him to use them? My son was alot like that, but around he would come up to me and hand me a book and say "Read". And I'd respond, "who do you want to read the book?" When he said "mommy" I'd respond "Ok, can you say Mommy read?" DS caught on pretty quick, but I'm not sure when he would have done it if we hadn't started to insist a bit.
Bad advice. Trying to get your kid to repeat stuff is not effective. Read "It Takes Two To Talk". It's completely worth it (it's expensive) and very useful in working out ways to play/talk with your child that will encourage communication, But saying "can you say..." is not helpful. That said, he's not behind yet. Goal is to be combining words BY two. My oldest didn't until a few months after he turned two. He's an exceptionally smart kid (taught himself to read at three, for example), so I figure if he didn't combine until past 2, I won't worry about my younger kid (who is 22 months and not combining).
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:havent seen ped since 18 month checkup. at 18 months, they said it was a 2 year milestone but we're coming up on 2 years
Okay, then wait for the appointment. IF, and that's a big IF, there is a speech problem, early intervention really can make a difference. And you'll get him what he needs. Until then, step away from the internet and enjoy your child.