They should.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So my Highland Lass costume was culturally insensitive? My neighbor's Leiderhosen as a halloween costume was culturally insensitive? What if it was a Highland Lass Zombie?

Do you have a connection with Scottish culture, on days that are not Halloween? Then you can wear a Highland Lass costume. Does your neighbor have a connection with German culture, on days that are not Halloween? Then your neighbor can wear Lederhosen as a costume. See how that works?

No that's not how it works. People wear Eddie Murphy costumes as Akeem with the tam and vest. Ever see his movie Coming to America? How many guys have worn Braveheart? Should those with Scotts ancestors tell their friends of Asian or AA descent they can't go as part of the Braveheart group?

Anonymous wrote:So my Highland Lass costume was culturally insensitive? My neighbor's Leiderhosen as a halloween costume was culturally insensitive? What if it was a Highland Lass Zombie?

Do you have a connection with Scottish culture, on days that are not Halloween? Then you can wear a Highland Lass costume. Does your neighbor have a connection with German culture, on days that are not Halloween? Then your neighbor can wear Lederhosen as a costume. See how that works?

Anonymous wrote:It's Halloween. If that's the most offensive thing you see on Halloween, you need to get out more.

Shorter PP: it's ok to be offensive, if other people are being more offensive.

Is it insensitive to dress a white child in full African garb or as an African tribesman? If you answer yes, then don't dress up your child like an Asian, American Indiana, etc. you are making a mockery.

So my Highland Lass costume was culturally insensitive? My neighbor's Leiderhosen as a halloween costume was culturally insensitive? What if it was a Highland Lass Zombie?

It's Halloween. If that's the most offensive thing you see on Halloween, you need to get out more.

OP, I think it's fine as long as you don't put her in make-up to make her look more Asian.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Someone's heritage or culture should not be used as a Halloween "costume".

Why?

Because its disrespectful.

How's that disrespectful? Is a cowboy costume disrespectful?

Cowboy isn't a heritage or a culture.

My friends in Wyoming and Arizona and Texas would beg to differ.

Sorry Halloween is yet another USA Holiday that offends people.

Hawaiin Shirts are sold out in large and XL.
http://www.partycity.com/product/dog+luau+costume.do?navSet=179239

Darn it. The English are now going to be offended:
http://www.partycity.com/product/robin+hood+dog+costume.do?navSet=179251

As well as Spanish descent in California with how to be Zorro and not have a license for the name:
http://www.partycity.com/product/boys+bandido+costume+elite.do?navSet=115917

How about those Italians?
http://www.partycity.com/product/boys+gladiator+costume.do?sortby=ourPicks&size=all&carousel=true&navSet=115917

The French:
http://www.partycity.com/product/boys+musketeer+costume+deluxe.do?sortby=ourPicks&size=all&carousel=true&navSet=115917

Anonymous wrote:Someone's heritage or culture should not be used as a Halloween "costume".

Yes. It's cultural appropriation. "And for Halloween, I'm dressing up as a stereotype of people from your country/culture!"

Anonymous wrote:Grrrrr. 2013 political correctness gone mad.

I know, right.
It was so much fun and so much easier when you could demean and marginize other cuter and races for your own amusement.
Now we actually have to think before we act, dang PC mind police.

I have a kimono that a colleague sent me for my DD (I work for a Japanese company). Can't wait to put her in it. I don't think it's offensive at all. If I saw a kid in a costume from my culture, I'd actually be pretty impressed.

Anonymous wrote:Cowboy is a profession. Like dressing up as a firefighter or farmer or cop.

A geisha is a profession, too. And it's not a prostitute like a lot of people may think.

Cowboy is a profession. Like dressing up as a firefighter or farmer or cop.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Someone's heritage or culture should not be used as a Halloween "costume".

Why?

Because its disrespectful.

How's that disrespectful? Is a cowboy costume disrespectful?

Cowboy isn't a heritage or a culture.

It is not? Think it is disrespectful because it's kind of like stereotyping a minority group. If whites were a minority and were not on the top of the food chain globally, wearing a cowboy costume might also seem disrespectful.