Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 20:51     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
I think the Breyers mint chocolate chip has remained the same. It's been one if my favorites for decades. I haven't had it since the summer and will be so disappointed if it's been altered.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 20:00     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla is all we buy.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:58     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Talenti
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:56     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Anonymous wrote:Trader Joe's ice cream.



+1 also WF 365 brand.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:51     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
+1 on Harris Teeter natural or Turkey Hill natural
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:06     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Talenti gelato.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:04     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
So disappointed in ice cream options lately. I'm making dessert for Christmas at the inlaws and wanted to get some ice cream to go with brownies - could only find one kind that didn't come with artificial ingredients and corn syrup.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 19:02     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Anonymous wrote:The new alll natural Harris Teeter kind reminds me of it -- melty and good flavor. The HD 5 is good, but heavier/richer.


I agree with Harris Teeter All Natural. The Neapolitan is very similar and part of me likes the chocolate better than Breyers.
Anonymous
Post 12/19/2014 18:27     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Bryers took homemade vanilla away and put vanilla bean back. So it's really buyer be ware! LOOK TO THE LABEL. Bryers still makes great ice cream; you just have to look for it. Thank-you Bryers!
Anonymous
Post 09/06/2013 20:37     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
I miss the old Breyers Mint Chocolate Chip. So good and I am not even an ice cream person! I will have to try HT Naturals.
Anonymous
Post 09/06/2013 18:21     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Graeters is nothing like the old Breyers. Graeters is wonderful, but so thick and rich that the spoon gets a coating of butterfat on it. The old Breyers was much less heavy.
Anonymous
Post 09/06/2013 18:18     Subject: Re:Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Graeters
Anonymous
Post 09/06/2013 18:08     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Anonymous wrote:Exactly, pp. I love Ben and Jerry's (coffee coffee buzz buzz flavor, handpacked from the shop, is irresistable). But old Breyer's vanilla, and their mint chocolate chip too, were a different thing, and so good. Now I might as well buy a carton of whatever old cheap ass ice cream there is.

Will try the HT though. Are the ingredients limited to the basics?


HT PP here -- I 've only had the vanilla and the cookie dough kinds, so there's at least some non-basic flavors.
Anonymous
Post 09/06/2013 17:47     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Anonymous wrote:Turkey Hill Natural. Not regular Turkey Hill.

There's always HD and B&J.


This is what I buy for my kids too. I find it too sweet and wish there were some options out there that weren't so sugary, but since I don't shop at Harris Teeter the Turkey Hill Natural is the only brand I could find that doesn't have additives.

Anonymous
Post 09/05/2013 15:20     Subject: Please recommend an ice cream like Breyer's used to be
Exactly, pp. I love Ben and Jerry's (coffee coffee buzz buzz flavor, handpacked from the shop, is irresistable). But old Breyer's vanilla, and their mint chocolate chip too, were a different thing, and so good. Now I might as well buy a carton of whatever old cheap ass ice cream there is.

Will try the HT though. Are the ingredients limited to the basics?