Anonymous wrote:OP Here. I appreciate the responses, and I'm trying to look at this from the other side.
There is a long and tortured history here, but the reality is that I don't trust my dad with my kids. I'm petrified of having my kids with him for any more than a lunch within walking distance of our house. My dad's driving is terrible, he falls asleep easily, and he is always on the phone. For example, he'll offer to take my kids to the park, but he'll spend the entire time on the phone not paying attention to them. He likes the idea of grandkids, but not really being with him.
While I simply could find some workarounds and ways for him to be with his kids, the problem is that he doesn't get boundaries. I've tried to talk with him about setting up times when the kids will be home, and he said that he "does not want to make an appointment." He wants to do things on his terms. (E.g., he wants to take kids horsebackriding; I've told him 100s of times that my DD is allergic). I begged him to teach my DD to ride a bike, but he isn't interested in that.
All that being said, I really will try to be more compassionate, but I would love any words of wisdom for how to get him to respect boundaries. I think it's fair to have time without him on my vacation.
Does he know you don't trust him with the kids? Or is it obvious even if unspoken?
I wonder if you approached it as getting what he wants: "Look, Dad, I know you don't want to make an appointment, but the thing is, if you wait until the last minute to arrange something with us, nine times out of ten the answer is going to be no. We tend to arrange things in advance--or we have to, because there's so much going on. I hate to disappoint you, and I want you to be involved in our lives. Is there any way you can ask a bit earlier than the day before? I'd be much more likely to say yes."
It also sounds like you need to accept that your dad isn't going to be the father and grandparent you wish he could be. You hate that he asks for the same thing over and over once you've said no--you should stop doing the same with him (over, for instance, the bike). Realize he's not going to have the role you want, and that if he won't change you will end up saying no a lot. That's just the breaks.