Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 23:47     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

In VA, the Springhill Rec Center has great classes. The other private academies all want a year to a three year contract ("to get your child to black belt" yeah, right). Do NOT sign one of these contracts. The usually Korean owner immediately sells the contracts at a discount so the contract is out of his hands. When you then go to him for complaints about smell, mold, hygiene of place, etc., he just shrugs. If you ask for your money back, he says "I sold contract". It's a HUGE racket. I think our contract was for $1300 for a year and we took a $900 loss. There is a long thread on the contract abuses these studios engage in. I reported ours to the VA attorney general who, at that time, was investigating all of the martial arts studios who demand the 1-2-3 year contracts and then immediate sell them at a discount so they can claim they can't give a refund. One poster was going to start up a class action against the studios. Check the yelp reports on them and you will see how angry people get at these martial arts studios. Go with your local rec center - our son did it and had a great time and we paid the standard session fee for @ 8-10 lessons.

Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 23:15     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Anonymous wrote:What am I missing in terms of the cost -- you need to rent space, usually not very big, need to put mats down and need a white suit, generally white? There are certainly some very good places out there but there are also many where it is just a place for kids to come for awhile and get a new belt (at a fee) every few months. When you are just starting out it is very difficult to tell the good from the fake places.


Salary, insurance, taxes, utilities, cleaning staff.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 23:10     Subject: Re:Karate is A Rip Off

Anonymous wrote:I did TKD for about 17 years (up until about 3 years ago, when I became pregnant with DD). Never paid more than $60/month at a small club run from a community center. And rather than being all about the belts, this school was legit and it took 5-7 years for an adult to become a black belt (and no black belts under age 16).

For PP suggesting martial arts schools need to make a huge profit -- sure they do, IF THEY ARE A BUSINESS and not an art form pursued by like-minded individuals and guided by an experienced practitioner who's in it for the love of the art instead of $$$. I would never join a for-profit martial arts school.



I am the pp you are addressing. I recognize there are many cheaper options such as the one you suggest. But recognize that your experience was subsidized by taxpayers and your instructor, and your tuition did not cover the true cost of your program. And that's ok. But a "ripoff" to me is when you don't get value for your money. I'm ok with paying a for profit business if i get what I am paying for. All well and good to be a purist but I think it promotes an exclusionary culture to only deem it unacceptable those instructors who teach purely for the love. Realistically who can afford to do that around here. Maybe part time but then that is a huge sacrifice to family time. If you want to keep tkd a small exclusive club then yes you are right. I happen to disagree.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 15:10     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Anonymous wrote:Just because an activity is both expensive and not right for your kid does not make it a "rip off." TKD has been tremendously beneficial for my kids, who both started at age 4. They are now 8 and 11 and love it. The confidence they have gained, the self-discipline, to ability to persevere, and the physical conditioning they have received from TKD have been worth every penny.

Also I will note that you may have observed lots of uncoordinated kids in class because TKD is a refuge for those kids who don't have natural athletic talent and struggle in team sports. That was my kid. He got hated on in both soccer and basketball. But now he can do 60 full pushups in a minute and can do the splits, and can jump and spin 360 degrees and land on his feet without breaking a sweat. And suddenly this year he has taken off in basketball because he has the work ethic and physical condition that others on his team lack.

Do you have any idea what the operating costs of a well-run martial arts studio are? Can you name one other activity with comparable overhead? Many athletic programs in our area are highly subsidized by taxpayer dolllars (baseball and soccer fields, community center gyms, school pools etc.) Any privately run business has operating costs. In this case, retail space, burdened pay (not just hourly salary but all the taxes, FICA, etc.), insurance (very expensive), equipment (dojo mats don't come cheap), cleaning crew (who wants to be in a grungy studio), and utilities (what do you think it costs to air condition a studio full of sweaty bodies?) And oh yeah, the owners are entitled to some kind of profit margin too, don't you think?

BS. ANY business costs money to run, but nobody rips off parents with contracts and high fees like TKD people. Simple as that.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 12:31     Subject: Re:Karate is A Rip Off

The TKD dojo that my family attends costs $120 a month for 4 people or $50 for one kid. Belts are earned and kids progress at different rates. If a kid kicked his sister in the face, and our teacher knew about it (maybe because the parents told him), the kid would be doing bear crawl laps, apologizing, and might get busted down a rank.

TKD and other martial arts are excellent for kids who need to learn to concentratel, and are commonly prescribed for kids with ADHD, because they work.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 12:11     Subject: Re:Karate is A Rip Off

I did TKD for about 17 years (up until about 3 years ago, when I became pregnant with DD). Never paid more than $60/month at a small club run from a community center. And rather than being all about the belts, this school was legit and it took 5-7 years for an adult to become a black belt (and no black belts under age 16).

For PP suggesting martial arts schools need to make a huge profit -- sure they do, IF THEY ARE A BUSINESS and not an art form pursued by like-minded individuals and guided by an experienced practitioner who's in it for the love of the art instead of $$$. I would never join a for-profit martial arts school.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 12:05     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

What am I missing in terms of the cost -- you need to rent space, usually not very big, need to put mats down and need a white suit, generally white? There are certainly some very good places out there but there are also many where it is just a place for kids to come for awhile and get a new belt (at a fee) every few months. When you are just starting out it is very difficult to tell the good from the fake places.
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 07:43     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Anonymous wrote:Just because an activity is both expensive and not right for your kid does not make it a "rip off." TKD has been tremendously beneficial for my kids, who both started at age 4. They are now 8 and 11 and love it. The confidence they have gained, the self-discipline, to ability to persevere, and the physical conditioning they have received from TKD have been worth every penny.

Also I will note that you may have observed lots of uncoordinated kids in class because TKD is a refuge for those kids who don't have natural athletic talent and struggle in team sports. That was my kid. He got hated on in both soccer and basketball. But now he can do 60 full pushups in a minute and can do the splits, and can jump and spin 360 degrees and land on his feet without breaking a sweat. And suddenly this year he has taken off in basketball because he has the work ethic and physical condition that others on his team lack.

Do you have any idea what the operating costs of a well-run martial arts studio are? Can you name one other activity with comparable overhead? Many athletic programs in our area are highly subsidized by taxpayer dolllars (baseball and soccer fields, community center gyms, school pools etc.) Any privately run business has operating costs. In this case, retail space, burdened pay (not just hourly salary but all the taxes, FICA, etc.), insurance (very expensive), equipment (dojo mats don't come cheap), cleaning crew (who wants to be in a grungy studio), and utilities (what do you think it costs to air condition a studio full of sweaty bodies?) And oh yeah, the owners are entitled to some kind of profit margin too, don't you think?



+1
Anonymous
Post 07/30/2013 07:14     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Agree 100% with PP. TKD is perfect for some kids.
Anonymous
Post 07/27/2013 19:25     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Just because an activity is both expensive and not right for your kid does not make it a "rip off." TKD has been tremendously beneficial for my kids, who both started at age 4. They are now 8 and 11 and love it. The confidence they have gained, the self-discipline, to ability to persevere, and the physical conditioning they have received from TKD have been worth every penny.

Also I will note that you may have observed lots of uncoordinated kids in class because TKD is a refuge for those kids who don't have natural athletic talent and struggle in team sports. That was my kid. He got hated on in both soccer and basketball. But now he can do 60 full pushups in a minute and can do the splits, and can jump and spin 360 degrees and land on his feet without breaking a sweat. And suddenly this year he has taken off in basketball because he has the work ethic and physical condition that others on his team lack.

Do you have any idea what the operating costs of a well-run martial arts studio are? Can you name one other activity with comparable overhead? Many athletic programs in our area are highly subsidized by taxpayer dolllars (baseball and soccer fields, community center gyms, school pools etc.) Any privately run business has operating costs. In this case, retail space, burdened pay (not just hourly salary but all the taxes, FICA, etc.), insurance (very expensive), equipment (dojo mats don't come cheap), cleaning crew (who wants to be in a grungy studio), and utilities (what do you think it costs to air condition a studio full of sweaty bodies?) And oh yeah, the owners are entitled to some kind of profit margin too, don't you think?

Anonymous
Post 07/11/2013 22:24     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

That summarizes it all. Let him kick a ball for the time being...
Anonymous
Post 07/11/2013 20:33     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

OP here. We decided not to pursue it for our six year old boy. He kicked his sister in the face. He's never done anything like that before. FWIW he had excellent report cards for behavior at school. Too expensive and obviously my son is too immature.
Anonymous
Post 07/06/2013 18:51     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

I just wanted to say that I totally agree that karate, martial arts, is a rip off. If you are going to pursue it, make sure you know why (all of the discipline kind of stuff does not work unless you have a real place) and select carefully. They are kind of like a pyramid scheme, and I think I could open a studio tomorrow, and lock you in for a year. At least at a fake gym, they generally need equipment.
Anonymous
Post 07/05/2013 22:18     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

Wait until your chdren are older and you know what it's really about. Then you can make a decision whether a martial art is appropriate. If its not, don't pay for it.
Anonymous
Post 07/05/2013 21:33     Subject: Karate is A Rip Off

I agree that it's way too much to pay for little kids and too long of a commitment.