Villanova has a better reputation (at least in the Philly area where I'm from), but it depends on their interests/potential majors.

Why is this a debate? They should go (1)where you can afford. And (2) where each wants to go. Even assuming one is the better school, kids should make college decisions based on where THEY feel would be the best fit.

We have three in college. All made VERY different college choices with little input from us.

^ it's also very strong in NYC, north jersey and pretty much all of New England. Big money areas.

The Villanova alumni network is very strong in Philly.