Anonymous wrote:At what point can these kids hold conversations in Mandarin? My Mandarin speaking friend was asked to speak to our neighbor's kid who is in k now. He just had a blank stare on his face the whole time. My friend switched to a very basic discussion- what is your name, what color is your shirt, etc...- still nothing. This is not a shy kid whatsoever.
Seriously doubt this is b/c the kid does not understand/speak Mandarin. It's difficult to get kids to speak another language besides English even if they are completely fluent. My nephews, 6 and 8, who are bilingual basically refuse to speak any language besides English when they are in the U.S. The deer in headlights look is pretty common.
My K kid can hold conversations in Mandarin pretty well. It's easier at school with people he knows b/c that's the way school's always been for him.