Current plan:
14 YO - magazine, metro card, nail polish and a nail kit, funky socks, toothbrush and paste, pens, jewlery or inexpensive watch

Typical Easter candy - bunny, jelly beans, other wrapped candy.

Thanks you for sharing your great ideas!

This is a great idea! We used to do something similar for end of year presents- one thing that always worked was an oversize (deliberately so, so it could fill all body types) tshirt appropriate for the age. Also, some unusual pens and notebooks.