Anonymous wrote:OP - I'm curious as to why you are replacing the Lazy Boy? We bought a sectional, sofa-bed, leather couch from Ashley about seven years ago. We love it. Then like clockwork, within weeks of the 7th anniversary the leather started peeling. In a matter of months it went from perfect to trashy. My husband was thinking Lazy Boy should be next, but I want quality. At a reasonable price.

OP here. The La-Z-Boy couch we have is NOT a reclining couch (as I said when I first posted). I really do not like the look of the reclining couches and would never buy one.
PP, the problem with our couch is that the seat is shallow for lounging comfortably, the cushions are completely shot, and several are ripping. Also the fabric that is attached to the base of the couch is coming off. It's been our main couch, but I would say that we have not abused the couch in any way, so I am surprised at how poorly it has held up. We have moved 3 times with it, so perhaps that is the problem. It was not pricey when we bought it, so perhaps if you are looking for something a bit pricier at the store you would get better quality.
We're just generally looking for a comfortable, roomy couch that is good for lounging and watching TV, but looks nice (no sagging cushions that have to be fluffed) that will hold up well in the main room of the house with kids and pets. As I said in my original post for others that asked, we would like to spend no more than $2000, preferably less since we also need to get a chair to go with the couch.