I would LOVE a MIL like that! MIL could use some skinny dipping, maybe the stick would fall out of her posterior.

I wouldn't skinny-dip with anyone. I'm kind of a prude about nudity. (and a total chicken about things that might be in the water with me, like jellyfish and stuff.) I'm not really the topless beach type either.

I'd like a MIL like that.. (though how comfortable I was with it would depend on who-all was there.) But skinny dipping, you're not parading around naked. Just getting in the water, and then back into your towel, then clothes... But I grew up skinny-dipping with family.

My MIL is a size 0 and I am a 10. No way.

I'd try to have a whitty comeback, like "Great joke, mom! I thought you were serious for a moment!"

I'd have to gouge out my eyes, immediately.

yikes... what kind of mother suggests/wants to see her grown children and their spouses naked? unless they are from a different culture/background, that is just plain weird.

I would be freaked out too.

I would do it if everyone else in the family were doing it. No big deal. Have breastfed in FIL's presence. Once you get that no one else is looking at your body in a sexual way because you are family it ceases to be an issue.

I would totally skinny dip with MIL (not American). FIL, or my parents...never ever ever.