Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

That's not what the Church teaches. So try again, bigot!

I guess you missed the sarcasm.

The bigotry you mean? Nope! You were loud and clear.

DP - if you genuinely believe something is an insidious evil, is it bigotry to hate that thing?

Sincerely asking your opinion, to know your definition of bigotry.

don’t waste your breath-that poster doesn’t know what the word bigotry means.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because the question is directed towards Catholics only. And why is that?

It is a shared Christian rule:

Baptist, Methodist, Pentecostal, Evangelical, and Eastern Orthodox churches all teach that sex belongs only in marriage.

Islam strictly forbids it:

In Islam, pre-marital sex is called Zina and is considered a major sin for all Muslims.

Orthodox Judaism prohibits it:

Traditional Jewish law (Halakha) completely forbids pre-marital sex and even bans unmarried men and women from touching.

So, again I will ask: why the fascination with Catholics? Bigotry or ignorance?

Because Catholics are always the loudest about this sort of “virtue” and it’s not even close.

It’s this exactly. Other religions/subsets also discourage sex before marriage but catholics make it a part of their personality. They bring it up, casually, often and that’s what makes people connect it with them before any other religion.
-Someone who went to college with a lot of catholics. Who made sure you knew they were catholic.

Anonymous wrote:Because the question is directed towards Catholics only. And why is that?

It is a shared Christian rule:

Baptist, Methodist, Pentecostal, Evangelical, and Eastern Orthodox churches all teach that sex belongs only in marriage.

Islam strictly forbids it:

In Islam, pre-marital sex is called Zina and is considered a major sin for all Muslims.

Orthodox Judaism prohibits it:

Traditional Jewish law (Halakha) completely forbids pre-marital sex and even bans unmarried men and women from touching.

So, again I will ask: why the fascination with Catholics? Bigotry or ignorance?

Because Catholics are always the loudest about this sort of “virtue” and it’s not even close.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

That's not what the Church teaches. So try again, bigot!

I guess you missed the sarcasm.

The bigotry you mean? Nope! You were loud and clear.

DP - if you genuinely believe something is an insidious evil, is it bigotry to hate that thing?

Sincerely asking your opinion, to know your definition of bigotry.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because the question is directed towards Catholics only. And why is that?

It is a shared Christian rule:

Baptist, Methodist, Pentecostal, Evangelical, and Eastern Orthodox churches all teach that sex belongs only in marriage.

Islam strictly forbids it:

In Islam, pre-marital sex is called Zina and is considered a major sin for all Muslims.

Orthodox Judaism prohibits it:

Traditional Jewish law (Halakha) completely forbids pre-marital sex and even bans unmarried men and women from touching.

So, again I will ask: why the fascination with Catholics? Bigotry or ignorance?

Did you miss the info in the description of this forum to not be easily offended? Clearly you did.

But fine, regardless if “any religion” prohibits sex before marriage what is the rule if you get divorced?

Since you seem to know everything about every religion-go ahead and answer specifically for all the ones you listed please.

Way to backpedal.

is the backpedaling in the room with us?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

That's not what the Church teaches. So try again, bigot!

I guess you missed the sarcasm.

The bigotry you mean? Nope! You were loud and clear.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Because the question is directed towards Catholics only. And why is that?

It is a shared Christian rule:

Baptist, Methodist, Pentecostal, Evangelical, and Eastern Orthodox churches all teach that sex belongs only in marriage.

Islam strictly forbids it:

In Islam, pre-marital sex is called Zina and is considered a major sin for all Muslims.

Orthodox Judaism prohibits it:

Traditional Jewish law (Halakha) completely forbids pre-marital sex and even bans unmarried men and women from touching.

So, again I will ask: why the fascination with Catholics? Bigotry or ignorance?

Did you miss the info in the description of this forum to not be easily offended? Clearly you did.

But fine, regardless if “any religion” prohibits sex before marriage what is the rule if you get divorced?

Since you seem to know everything about every religion-go ahead and answer specifically for all the ones you listed please.

Way to backpedal.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

That's not what the Church teaches. So try again, bigot!

I guess you missed the sarcasm.

Divorce in and of itself is not a sin, although as a PP pointed out many of the behaviors that might lead to one could be sinful. Divorce actually is required before a petition for a declaration of nullity can be filed in a Church court. The commonly used term “annulment,” is confusing because nothing actually is made null in the relevant proceeding. What is tested is whether a sacramental marriage ever occurred in the first instance. The kinds of behavior that lead to civil divorce often weigh heavily in favor of a conclusion that one or both parties lacked the requisite maturity and psychological ability to form a sacramental union that is permanent, exclusive and open to the transmission of life. PP’s are correct that sexual activity outside valid marriage violates Catholic moral teaching.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

That's not what the Church teaches. So try again, bigot!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Yes those dirty sinners! Stay with that husband who abuses you. the church doesn’t want you to be happy if you leave him-your life should just be filled with perpetual sadness.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.

No, idiot, not in the eyes of the Catholic Church. There is no second or third or fourth marriage in the eyes of the Church. There’s only the one. So any sex after that is “outside” of it.

Anonymous wrote:It is not sex before marriage, it is sex outside of a marriage (thus why sex before marriage is an issue)

So yes, divorced people should also remain celibate unless remarried.

Semantics. There is literally no difference. Because it would still be sex BEFORE a second marriage or a third or fourth.