Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
It's fine to say support harsh prosecution as an act of vengeance. You could even argue it is important for maintaining credibility in the legal system as a whole.
But it is ridiculous to claim it has a deterrent effect.
Punishment won't fix this problem. We need something else.
So you’d be ok if your neighbor left a gun out and your kid shot themselves. I mean why imprison people who kill their children? It happens all the time and doesn’t seem to stop anyone.
Anonymous wrote:And yet, we have no common sense gun laws.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
It's fine to say support harsh prosecution as an act of vengeance. You could even argue it is important for maintaining credibility in the legal system as a whole.
But it is ridiculous to claim it has a deterrent effect.
Punishment won't fix this problem. We need something else.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
It's fine to say support harsh prosecution as an act of vengeance. You could even argue it is important for maintaining credibility in the legal system as a whole.
But it is ridiculous to claim it has a deterrent effect.
Punishment won't fix this problem. We need something else.
Better screening and training before a gun license is given, +/- regular renewal requirements, to ensure that the individual who wants to own a gun will be responsible and safe. Same level of scrutiny as getting a driver’s license.
Clearly, there are people who are responsible as gun owners, and clearly, there are people who are not responsible.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
It's fine to say support harsh prosecution as an act of vengeance. You could even argue it is important for maintaining credibility in the legal system as a whole.
But it is ridiculous to claim it has a deterrent effect.
Punishment won't fix this problem. We need something else.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
It's fine to say support harsh prosecution as an act of vengeance. You could even argue it is important for maintaining credibility in the legal system as a whole.
But it is ridiculous to claim it has a deterrent effect.
Punishment won't fix this problem. We need something else.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
But if you’d kid shot themselves at your neighbor’s house you’d be in favor of punishment no? We don’t own our children.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This is worse than forgetting your child in a car on a hot day, surely the consequences should be worse. But it’s America so…
So, here's my problem with that mindset: heavy punishment of parents in these cases might feel good, but it won't actually deter the bad behavior of others. It ultimately distracts from the need for changes that otherwise could have a positive effect.
word salad.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:So it was loaded? Stored while loaded? Stored somewhere this child could access it? Not locked?
All of which are illegal in Maryland.
Major, major failure.
I hope they throw the book at this family. Maybe it will save their other children, if they have them, or a neighbor or family member that was lacking in their own gun safety. I don't believe in "they already lost a child, that's punishment enough", I don't think it is.
I don't get what you think "throwing the book" at the family would accomplish. You think that prison time is more of a deterrent than losing your child? Maybe to some, but would certainly be the exception.