Anonymous
02/06/2026 19:03
Subject: Alchemised
Agree to disagree on the use of the word, I guess. I love reading smut. There are sex scenes, but the SA immediately makes all other sex scenes in this book not at all sexy IMO.Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Not at all. This is a dark fantasy. It was one of those fics I could only read once because it was so devastating. Just full ugly crying. It’s not romantic. It’s not sexy. I actually think it’s really weird when people thirst over this main character (although that seems to be a small percentage of people). But yes, people hear fanfic and assume it’s smut. Not this one.Anonymous wrote:Just from the title I'm guessing this is Draco/Hermione p*rn, right? I've read a bunch of these and I only liked one, the good one. These authors play fast and loose with characters and I don't like the dom/sub thing.
It’s definitely smut!
Anonymous
02/06/2026 18:43
Subject: Alchemised
Anonymous wrote:Not at all. This is a dark fantasy. It was one of those fics I could only read once because it was so devastating. Just full ugly crying. It’s not romantic. It’s not sexy. I actually think it’s really weird when people thirst over this main character (although that seems to be a small percentage of people). But yes, people hear fanfic and assume it’s smut. Not this one.Anonymous wrote:Just from the title I'm guessing this is Draco/Hermione p*rn, right? I've read a bunch of these and I only liked one, the good one. These authors play fast and loose with characters and I don't like the dom/sub thing.
It’s definitely smut!
Anonymous
02/06/2026 17:26
Subject: Alchemised
Anonymous wrote:Was the PP denying the history with Manacled (or just not aware), or were they implying the edits to the characters, plot, and magic system was enough to separate it from HP origins so it doesn’t read like HP fanfiction? Honestly not sure.Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'm not touching anything that comes close to the HP and the nasty TERF who wrote it.
There is so much awesome fantasy out there. We need to leave JKR in a ditch.
It’s not anywhere close to Hp.
Oh hon. You don't know anything about this book. It's HP Fan Fiction that was edited for trad publication. Google it.
I wrote the not anywhere near HP. I came to this book without knowing any of the back story, and glad I did.
Anonymous
02/06/2026 14:26
Subject: Alchemised
Was the PP denying the history with Manacled (or just not aware), or were they implying the edits to the characters, plot, and magic system was enough to separate it from HP origins so it doesn’t read like HP fanfiction? Honestly not sure.Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'm not touching anything that comes close to the HP and the nasty TERF who wrote it.
There is so much awesome fantasy out there. We need to leave JKR in a ditch.
It’s not anywhere close to Hp.
Oh hon. You don't know anything about this book. It's HP Fan Fiction that was edited for trad publication. Google it.
Anonymous
02/06/2026 11:36
Subject: Alchemised
If you come to this book not knowing the background it actually might be better. Because, who cares.