Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My daughter has had “first dinner” and “second dinner” all through middle school. This is not a big deal to me at all. But she had a lot of relatively healthy things for those two dinners. If she says she is starving, I ask her to go for some protein or fruit before the chocolate cake. But she doesn’t have a weight problem. She is 75% percentile for weight, which has always been her number. And she is 95% for height.
You seem to have a lot of weight gain here and a lot of access to junky food. This is worth talking to a doctor about. But don’t take away 2 healthy dinners for an active kid in middle school.
I’m not OP but my DS with ADHD has binge eating. It is a completely different thing than what you are describing. You are describing a healthy, normal appetite.
I get that if you don’t have experience with binge eating, it’s hard to understand.
Well, I have a lot of expertise being an obese binge eater myself. And honestly, it isn’t clear to me that the OP is actually describing binge eating versus pretty normal teen eating. She may be an unreliable narrator. Saying things like her teen eats when the parents aren’t watching and eats basically a dinner right after school seem more like she has her own eating issues than her tween does. What teen has to not eat until their parents get home? This sounds nutty to me. And I have no idea what this “enormous” amount is the kid has gained. This is why I suggested she talk to a doctor who can look at this situation. Most of what she describes would apply to all the 13 year old girls that come to slumber parties and go to our beach house. They put down large amounts of food and eat two dinners.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My daughter has had “first dinner” and “second dinner” all through middle school. This is not a big deal to me at all. But she had a lot of relatively healthy things for those two dinners. If she says she is starving, I ask her to go for some protein or fruit before the chocolate cake. But she doesn’t have a weight problem. She is 75% percentile for weight, which has always been her number. And she is 95% for height.
You seem to have a lot of weight gain here and a lot of access to junky food. This is worth talking to a doctor about. But don’t take away 2 healthy dinners for an active kid in middle school.
I’m not OP but my DS with ADHD has binge eating. It is a completely different thing than what you are describing. You are describing a healthy, normal appetite.
I get that if you don’t have experience with binge eating, it’s hard to understand.
Well, I have a lot of expertise being an obese binge eater myself. And honestly, it isn’t clear to me that the OP is actually describing binge eating versus pretty normal teen eating. She may be an unreliable narrator. Saying things like her teen eats when the parents aren’t watching and eats basically a dinner right after school seem more like she has her own eating issues than her tween does. What teen has to not eat until their parents get home? This sounds nutty to me. And I have no idea what this “enormous” amount is the kid has gained. This is why I suggested she talk to a doctor who can look at this situation. Most of what she describes would apply to all the 13 year old girls that come to slumber parties and go to our beach house. They put down large amounts of food and eat two dinners.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My daughter has had “first dinner” and “second dinner” all through middle school. This is not a big deal to me at all. But she had a lot of relatively healthy things for those two dinners. If she says she is starving, I ask her to go for some protein or fruit before the chocolate cake. But she doesn’t have a weight problem. She is 75% percentile for weight, which has always been her number. And she is 95% for height.
You seem to have a lot of weight gain here and a lot of access to junky food. This is worth talking to a doctor about. But don’t take away 2 healthy dinners for an active kid in middle school.
I’m not OP but my DS with ADHD has binge eating. It is a completely different thing than what you are describing. You are describing a healthy, normal appetite.
I get that if you don’t have experience with binge eating, it’s hard to understand.
Anonymous wrote:My daughter has had “first dinner” and “second dinner” all through middle school. This is not a big deal to me at all. But she had a lot of relatively healthy things for those two dinners. If she says she is starving, I ask her to go for some protein or fruit before the chocolate cake. But she doesn’t have a weight problem. She is 75% percentile for weight, which has always been her number. And she is 95% for height.
You seem to have a lot of weight gain here and a lot of access to junky food. This is worth talking to a doctor about. But don’t take away 2 healthy dinners for an active kid in middle school.