Anonymous wrote:This is a t-shirt dress to me, for clarification

https://www.lilysilk.com/us/the-scarlet-shirtdress.html

Interesting. I think this is a t shirt dress.

https://athleta.gap.com/browse/product.do?pid=842888072&vid=3&tid=atpl000086&kwid=1&ap=7&ds_agid=22314961672-&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22314975253&gbraid=0AAAAAD_AT8td3EQo3WpR0g60TCiHBzYJP&gclid=Cj0KCQjwyIPDBhDBARIsAHJyyViVPOcAkaKCOUmHgMxiekFW4I0zg8Co301xWzRszRbjYHson307Q5QaAtnqEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds#pdp-page-content

This is a t-shirt dress to me, for clarification

https://www.lilysilk.com/us/the-scarlet-shirtdress.html

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:T shirt dresses do not work on me (I have a small waist but smallish boobs and bigger butt/thighs). A tshirt dress on me is droopy on top and tight on my hips. I actually am going to differ with most of the opinions and say I see t-shirt dresses looking great on women with BIG boobs and a firm but curvy body. I think the bust making the t-shirt dress not cling to the stomach is key. Apple or upside-down triangle is what I'm saying.

Of course, everything looks good on tall and skinny.

Tshirt dresses look awful on everyone. They are nightgowns.

T-shirt dresses are entirely different from the shirt dresses OP is asking about. If you look good in one, very likely you don't look good in the other.

Anonymous wrote:T shirt dresses do not work on me (I have a small waist but smallish boobs and bigger butt/thighs). A tshirt dress on me is droopy on top and tight on my hips. I actually am going to differ with most of the opinions and say I see t-shirt dresses looking great on women with BIG boobs and a firm but curvy body. I think the bust making the t-shirt dress not cling to the stomach is key. Apple or upside-down triangle is what I'm saying.

Of course, everything looks good on tall and skinny.

Tshirt dresses look awful on everyone. They are nightgowns.

T shirt dresses do not work on me (I have a small waist but smallish boobs and bigger butt/thighs). A tshirt dress on me is droopy on top and tight on my hips. I actually am going to differ with most of the opinions and say I see t-shirt dresses looking great on women with BIG boobs and a firm but curvy body. I think the bust making the t-shirt dress not cling to the stomach is key. Apple or upside-down triangle is what I'm saying.

Of course, everything looks good on tall and skinny.

Anonymous wrote:Thank you for all the interesting comments. One thing that strikes me reading everyone’s thoughts is that the cut of the shirt of dress matters a lot because I was not thinking of the type in the link or descriptions.

I was thinking this kind of cut but it’s not flattering on me.

https://www.jcrew.com/p/womens/categories/clothing/dresses-and-jumpsuits/elena-shirtdress-in-cotton-poplin/BY832?color_name=white&N=8&noPopUp=true&srcCode=Paid_Search%7CShopping_NonBrand%7CGoogle%7CPMG%5EG%5E99107384936_20292560301___m_pla_online__9007768&utm_source=Google&utm_medium=paid_search&utm_content=shopping_ads&utm_campaign=JCrew_Shopping_PLA_US_All_Dresses_PMax_Womens_Google+_X&utm_term=&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19965637641&gbraid=0AAAAADqAteDTHYPiChx_AWzTnSuRTLZZV&gclid=Cj0KCQjwpf7CBhCfARIsANIETVpq30iqq9zxQoVDrK97sgeQP98IZmnBWq_LJQvgUkH9FJpjyAtU5-0aAibMEALw_wcB#no_universal_links%23no_universal_links

I know someone who wears these regularly to work. She is very petite. 100 lbs or so.

5-5 and 128. I went to Catholic High School in the 70s and some of the pastel colored ones look too much like our summer uniforms to me. Also, dresses like the JCrew one upthread with a gathered skirt have just too much fabric for my frame. I do best with belted straight up and down ones like they have at JMac.

Anonymous wrote:I'm average and hourglass - 5'7, 130 lbs - and they look good on me. I get the belted ones.

You are very thin

6 feet, give or take an inch. Very thin. Anyone saying otherwise is lying or deluded.

Good bodies can wear anything and still look good.

Others have to wear specific clothing to hide flaws and accentuate their good parts.

I have an asymmetrical one that looks great. Belted, ankle length on one side and midi on the other. I'm 5'4" and 120lbs.

Anonymous wrote:Thank you for all the interesting comments. One thing that strikes me reading everyone’s thoughts is that the cut of the shirt of dress matters a lot because I was not thinking of the type in the link or descriptions.

I was thinking this kind of cut but it’s not flattering on me.

https://www.jcrew.com/p/womens/categories/clothing/dresses-and-jumpsuits/elena-shirtdress-in-cotton-poplin/BY832?color_name=white&N=8&noPopUp=true&srcCode=Paid_Search%7CShopping_NonBrand%7CGoogle%7CPMG%5EG%5E99107384936_20292560301___m_pla_online__9007768&utm_source=Google&utm_medium=paid_search&utm_content=shopping_ads&utm_campaign=JCrew_Shopping_PLA_US_All_Dresses_PMax_Womens_Google+_X&utm_term=&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19965637641&gbraid=0AAAAADqAteDTHYPiChx_AWzTnSuRTLZZV&gclid=Cj0KCQjwpf7CBhCfARIsANIETVpq30iqq9zxQoVDrK97sgeQP98IZmnBWq_LJQvgUkH9FJpjyAtU5-0aAibMEALw_wcB#no_universal_links%23no_universal_links

I am the pear above who said shirt dresses with inset waists and an aline or fuller skirt are my favorite style of dress. I actually own this dress in another color. It is flattering because I have a smaller waist and chest.

Some think of shirt dresses as basically a longer version of a man's shirt that may be worn belted or unbelted. This isn't a style that works for me because my hips are too wide. A size that would fit them would be way too big in the shoulders. It is a style that could work for women who have waists that are wider relative to their hips.

They work on me as long as they're tailored and not too voluminous. I'm petite, thin, and not curvy.

Thank you for all the interesting comments. One thing that strikes me reading everyone’s thoughts is that the cut of the shirt of dress matters a lot because I was not thinking of the type in the link or descriptions.

I was thinking this kind of cut but it’s not flattering on me.

https://www.jcrew.com/p/womens/categories/clothing/dresses-and-jumpsuits/elena-shirtdress-in-cotton-poplin/BY832?color_name=white&N=8&noPopUp=true&srcCode=Paid_Search%7CShopping_NonBrand%7CGoogle%7CPMG%5EG%5E99107384936_20292560301___m_pla_online__9007768&utm_source=Google&utm_medium=paid_search&utm_content=shopping_ads&utm_campaign=JCrew_Shopping_PLA_US_All_Dresses_PMax_Womens_Google+_X&utm_term=&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19965637641&gbraid=0AAAAADqAteDTHYPiChx_AWzTnSuRTLZZV&gclid=Cj0KCQjwpf7CBhCfARIsANIETVpq30iqq9zxQoVDrK97sgeQP98IZmnBWq_LJQvgUkH9FJpjyAtU5-0aAibMEALw_wcB#no_universal_links%23no_universal_links

I like them but I have to shorten them and I avoid the midi length. I’m 5’2”.