Anonymous
05/28/2025 17:13
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Go check out Rehobeth vs. Dewey vs. Bethany/Fenwick Island vs. O.C. and see which you prefer. Personally, my preference would be Bethany/Fenwick very close to 142nd Street ocean city. There's so much to do in O.C.
Anonymous
05/28/2025 17:08
Subject: Re:What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Alonzo's, Don Tony's, Buck Stops There, Hobby House, Luigi's Spin Hut.
Anonymous
05/28/2025 16:34
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Touch of Italy in Rehobeth
Anonymous
05/28/2025 12:57
Subject: Re:What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Definitely not going to Bethany Beach for pizza.
The Grottos pie looks like chuck-e-cheese.
Pomodoro slices could be mistaken for AdMo drunk slices.
Reading comprehension is not your friend PP.
Anonymous
05/28/2025 09:14
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Real answer: Lili's
Grotto's is gross.
Pomodoro is solid, but overpriced.
Kinda wish there was a Ledo Pizza out at Bethany.
Weird, why? You can get that at home. Plus its greasy as heck.
Anonymous
05/28/2025 01:19
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This thread is hilarious being from NYC....forget about getting a decent slice in lower slower DE.
I love NY pizza and always get it in NYC which I have been to so many times over the years and still go every year. Have you tried Pomodoro, because it’s the closest to NY pizza I have found anywhere outside of NYC.
BTW, the owners are new yorkers.
I have tried Pomodoro's, I find it just average.
Anonymous
05/28/2025 00:45
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:This thread is hilarious being from NYC....forget about getting a decent slice in lower slower DE.
I love NY pizza and always get it in NYC which I have been to so many times over the years and still go every year. Have you tried Pomodoro, because it’s the closest to NY pizza I have found anywhere outside of NYC.
BTW, the owners are new yorkers.
Anonymous
05/27/2025 23:56
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
This thread is hilarious being from NYC....forget about getting a decent slice in lower slower DE.
Anonymous
05/27/2025 23:36
Subject: Re:What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Definitely Pomodoro. There is a reason there is a two hour wait for pickup every weekend!
Anonymous
05/27/2025 21:44
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Drive to Rehoboth and get Nicola’s.
THIS!
Drive to Rehoboth and get Louie’s!
Anonymous
05/27/2025 21:39
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Drive to Rehoboth and get Nicola’s.
THIS!
Anonymous
05/27/2025 14:57
Subject: Re:What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Anonymous wrote:Definitely not going to Bethany Beach for pizza.
The Grottos pie looks like chuck-e-cheese.
Pomodoro slices could be mistaken for AdMo drunk slices.
lol Pomodoro's has a big sign at the cashier stating "NO SINGLE SLICES AFTER 4PM!!!"
Anonymous
05/27/2025 13:45
Subject: Re:What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Definitely not going to Bethany Beach for pizza.
The Grottos pie looks like chuck-e-cheese.
Pomodoro slices could be mistaken for AdMo drunk slices.
The Grottos pie looks like chuck-e-cheese.
Pomodoro slices could be mistaken for AdMo drunk slices.
Anonymous
05/27/2025 13:15
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
I like Surf's Up in town near the boardwalk.
Anonymous
05/27/2025 13:14
Subject: What is the BEST pizza place in Bethany Beach?
Real answer: Lili's
Grotto's is gross.
Pomodoro is solid, but overpriced.
Kinda wish there was a Ledo Pizza out at Bethany.
Grotto's is gross.
Pomodoro is solid, but overpriced.
Kinda wish there was a Ledo Pizza out at Bethany.