Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:43     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Carvel. I will die on that hill.
Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:42     Subject: Best ice cream cake
DQ all the way. The ones with actual cake in them are horrible.
Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:39     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Baskin-Robins
Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:38     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Cold Stone sucks.


I actually really like the taste of Cold Stone. But if you look at the ingredients list, yuck.


You can’t use real cake ingredients for ice cream cake. The mouthfeel will be all wrong. Cake made from butter and so forth isn’t supposed to be eaten frozen. You need those “bad” ingredients.
Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:26     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Baskin Robbins, no question.


+1
Anonymous
Post 05/17/2025 07:16     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Bruster's ice crem shop has great cakes (and pies).



+10. This is a no cake ice cream cake which is important to me. Who wants frozen cake,!


Wait there are people out there who want all-ice cream ice cream cakes? Isn't that just a square of ice cream with frosting? At that point just buy a gallon of ice cream and a tub of frosting.


Yes many people do not want to eat frozen cake. My favorite is Brusters Ice cream pie. Start with chocolate or graham crust then a choice of a "gooey layer", then ice cream, then frosting.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 15:50     Subject: Best ice cream cake
The Cold Stone Oreo cake that has golden Oreos and regular Oreos on it is really good. And the cake is soft and tasty, not a dry tasteless slab like Baskin Robbins.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 15:30     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Don't care what anyone says, nothing beats fudgie the whale, and I'm a food snob.


I’m partial to Cookiepuss.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 15:29     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:They are really easy to make - even the little chocolate crunchies!


? just crunched up oreos?
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 14:44     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Dairy Queen is the best!


100%

Anything with a frozen piece of cake in there is nasty.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 14:39     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Bruster's ice crem shop has great cakes (and pies).



+10. This is a no cake ice cream cake which is important to me. Who wants frozen cake,!


Wait there are people out there who want all-ice cream ice cream cakes? Isn't that just a square of ice cream with frosting? At that point just buy a gallon of ice cream and a tub of frosting.


Everyone knows that you buy ice cream cake for the crunchies.
Anonymous
Post 05/16/2025 14:33     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Bruster's ice crem shop has great cakes (and pies).



+10. This is a no cake ice cream cake which is important to me. Who wants frozen cake,!


Wait there are people out there who want all-ice cream ice cream cakes? Isn't that just a square of ice cream with frosting? At that point just buy a gallon of ice cream and a tub of frosting.
Anonymous
Post 05/15/2025 09:14     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Don't care what anyone says, nothing beats fudgie the whale, and I'm a food snob.
Anonymous
Post 05/15/2025 08:58     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Anonymous wrote:Cold Stone sucks.


I actually really like the taste of Cold Stone. But if you look at the ingredients list, yuck.
Anonymous
Post 05/14/2025 16:51     Subject: Best ice cream cake
Dairy Queen is the best!