Anonymous wrote:Pretty sure OP is a troll, everyone.

You mean they want to start a fight? That's fine. Calm responses that inform other readers of this thread are very helpful to combat anti-Muslim sentiment.

Pretty sure OP is a troll, everyone.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Do Muslims traditionally acknowledge that the Virgin Mary is a Jew?

Again, Islam is an Abrahamic religion. Meaning that Muslims consider their religion to be a continuation of Judaism and Christianity (“people of the book”)

So why do they hate Christians and Jews? Seems weird if they are all related.

They don't hate. Only extremists hate. The immense majority of people of faith in the world, Muslim, Christian, Jew, Buddhist, Hindu, etc, do not hate people of other faiths.

You really need to get out of your weird media bubble if you equate Islam with hate. That's actually incredibly offensive for you to type out.

Yes, very much so.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Do Muslims traditionally acknowledge that the Virgin Mary is a Jew?

Again, Islam is an Abrahamic religion. Meaning that Muslims consider their religion to be a continuation of Judaism and Christianity (“people of the book”)

So why do they hate Christians and Jews? Seems weird if they are all related.

Anonymous wrote:Do Muslims traditionally acknowledge that the Virgin Mary is a Jew?

Again, Islam is an Abrahamic religion. Meaning that Muslims consider their religion to be a continuation of Judaism and Christianity (“people of the book”)

Anonymous wrote:Someone was telling me recently that Muslims greatly revere the Virgin Mary. Is this true?

Yes, and Jesus, Moses, etc.. are considered prophets in Islam. It is an abrahamic religion after all.

Do Muslims traditionally acknowledge that the Virgin Mary is a Jew?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Jesus’ mother is an historical figure. Only Catholics believe she was a virgin and Jesus her only child.

Catholics don’t believe Jesus is our only child

BUt yo think she was a virgin when she conceived Jesus, right?

Yes but she had children after Jesus.

In Mark 6:3 it says he had 6 siblings.

Jesus is believed to have had at least six siblings: four brothers named James, Joseph, Judas, and Simon, and at least two unnamed sisters. The New Testament mentions these siblings in Mark and Matthew

Protestant here, but this is a modern and overly-literal take. James and Jude both self-identify as brothers of Jesus in their epistles, and there are other mentions in the Gospels as you say, but the word "brothers" in this context has long been shown to be easily understood as "cousins" or "relatives". Furthermore, even if they are literal "brothers" that's not to say that they aren't stepbrothers who were sons of Joseph from a prior marriage.

This is not (only) Catholic magisterium: all the Reformers held to the perpetual virginity of Mary (look up Calvin, Luther, Cranmer, Vermigli, etc.).

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Jesus’ mother is an historical figure. Only Catholics believe she was a virgin and Jesus her only child.

Catholics don’t believe Jesus is our only child

What do you mean by this?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Jesus’ mother is an historical figure. Only Catholics believe she was a virgin and Jesus her only child.

Catholics don’t believe Jesus is our only child

BUt yo think she was a virgin when she conceived Jesus, right?

Yes but she had children after Jesus.

In Mark 6:3 it says he had 6 siblings.

Jesus is believed to have had at least six siblings: four brothers named James, Joseph, Judas, and Simon, and at least two unnamed sisters. The New Testament mentions these siblings in Mark and Matthew

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Jesus’ mother is an historical figure. Only Catholics believe she was a virgin and Jesus her only child.

Catholics don’t believe Jesus is our only child

BUt yo think she was a virgin when she conceived Jesus, right?

Anonymous wrote:Jesus’ mother is an historical figure. Only Catholics believe she was a virgin and Jesus her only child.

Catholics don’t believe Jesus is our only child

Anonymous wrote:The Quran identifies four women as being amongst the best in Paradise: Maryam bint 'Imran (Mary, the mother of Jesus), Khadijah bint Khuwaylid (Muhammad's first wife), Fatimah bint Muhammad (Muhammad's youngest daughter), and Asiyah bint Muzahim (Pharaoh's wife who saved baby Moses). These women are recognized for their piety, devotion, and strong faith.

And doing something child related

The Quran identifies four women as being amongst the best in Paradise: Maryam bint 'Imran (Mary, the mother of Jesus), Khadijah bint Khuwaylid (Muhammad's first wife), Fatimah bint Muhammad (Muhammad's youngest daughter), and Asiyah bint Muzahim (Pharaoh's wife who saved baby Moses). These women are recognized for their piety, devotion, and strong faith.