Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What you want to happen is for an immigration judge to change his status, to revoke his withholding of removal due to changed country conditions. Or maybe to retroactively find him uncredible.
Either of those things, which are things that we never actually do, would happen here, in the United States. Bring him here and make those things happen. Don't send him to a foreign prison for the crime of ... not applying for asylum in a timely fashion.
He should have been deported in 2019, but the prior administration didn't have its act together and let him slip through. This gave false hope to him and the horde of undocumented migrants crashing through the border.
Anonymous wrote:
April 14, 2025: El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele refused to return him, calling him a "terrorist" and asserting that his legal status is now up to El Salvador's laws.
.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What you want to happen is for an immigration judge to change his status, to revoke his withholding of removal due to changed country conditions. Or maybe to retroactively find him uncredible.
Either of those things, which are things that we never actually do, would happen here, in the United States. Bring him here and make those things happen. Don't send him to a foreign prison for the crime of ... not applying for asylum in a timely fashion.
He should have been deported in 2019, but the prior administration didn't have its act together and let him slip through. This gave false hope to him and the horde of undocumented migrants crashing through the border.
Anonymous wrote:What you want to happen is for an immigration judge to change his status, to revoke his withholding of removal due to changed country conditions. Or maybe to retroactively find him uncredible.
Either of those things, which are things that we never actually do, would happen here, in the United States. Bring him here and make those things happen. Don't send him to a foreign prison for the crime of ... not applying for asylum in a timely fashion.
Anonymous wrote:2011 (Age 16): Illegally entered the U.S. from El Salvador. Did not apply for asylum upon arrival, despite being of legal age and allegedly fleeing gang threats.
2011–2019 (Ages 16–23): Lived in Maryland without legal status. Never filed for asylum during this entire period.
March 2019 (Age 23): Arrested in Maryland. Only then did he claim fear of gang persecution, citing threats to his family’s store—a claim not previously mentioned and for which there is no confirmation he was involved in the business at all.
2019: Asylum application denied due to being filed too late. Granted "withholding of removal," which is temporary protection—not legal status or a path to citizenship.
June 2019: Married a U.S. citizen shortly after legal options narrowed—raising concerns about the motive and timing.
March 2022: El Salvador began a nationwide gang crackdown under President Nayib Bukele. Over 85,000 suspected gang members arrested.
2024: El Salvador’s homicide rate dropped to 1.9 per 100,000, making it one of the safest countries in the region. The gang threat cited in his claim is no longer considered a valid basis for asylum.
January 20, 2025: President Trump signed Executive Order 14155 to suspend the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program (USRAP), effective January 27, 2025—halting refugee admissions and pausing pending cases.
March 12, 2025 (Age 29): Detained by ICE during a traffic stop and told his immigration status had changed.
March 15, 2025: Deported to El Salvador and imprisoned in the CECOT high-security facility.
April 10, 2025: U.S. Supreme Court ruled the deportation was illegal and ordered the administration to "facilitate" his return.
April 14, 2025: El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele refused to return him, calling him a "terrorist" and asserting that his legal status is now up to El Salvador's laws.
He was old enough to claim asylum in 2011 but waited until after getting caught in 2019.
His persecution claim was based on an unverifiable threat to a business he may not have even been part of.
El Salvador is now safer, and the gang violence cited in his claim has been dismantled.
Anonymous wrote:2011 (Age 16): Illegally entered the U.S. from El Salvador. Did not apply for asylum upon arrival, despite being of legal age and allegedly fleeing gang threats.
2011–2019 (Ages 16–23): Lived in Maryland without legal status. Never filed for asylum during this entire period.
March 2019 (Age 23): Arrested in Maryland. Only then did he claim fear of gang persecution, citing threats to his family’s store—a claim not previously mentioned and for which there is no confirmation he was involved in the business at all.
2019: Asylum application denied due to being filed too late. Granted "withholding of removal," which is temporary protection—not legal status or a path to citizenship.
June 2019: Married a U.S. citizen shortly after legal options narrowed—raising concerns about the motive and timing.
March 2022: El Salvador began a nationwide gang crackdown under President Nayib Bukele. Over 85,000 suspected gang members arrested.
2024: El Salvador’s homicide rate dropped to 1.9 per 100,000, making it one of the safest countries in the region. The gang threat cited in his claim is no longer considered a valid basis for asylum.
January 20, 2025: President Trump signed Executive Order 14155 to suspend the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program (USRAP), effective January 27, 2025—halting refugee admissions and pausing pending cases.
March 12, 2025 (Age 29): Detained by ICE during a traffic stop and told his immigration status had changed.
March 15, 2025: Deported to El Salvador and imprisoned in the CECOT high-security facility.
April 10, 2025: U.S. Supreme Court ruled the deportation was illegal and ordered the administration to "facilitate" his return.
April 14, 2025: El Salvador’s President Nayib Bukele refused to return him, calling him a "terrorist" and asserting that his legal status is now up to El Salvador's laws.
He was old enough to claim asylum in 2011 but waited until after getting caught in 2019.
His persecution claim was based on an unverifiable threat to a business he may not have even been part of.
El Salvador is now safer, and the gang violence cited in his claim has been dismantled.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It's like having mexico deport a us citizen to the US and giving them back to Mexico. He needs to work with his own country m
It's not, no. You've not only got the wrong end of the stick, you've got the wrong stick entirely.
Anonymous wrote:It's like having mexico deport a us citizen to the US and giving them back to Mexico. He needs to work with his own country m
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I’m guessing he’s been raped and tortured. So far as Trump is concerned, better dead or disappeared than alive and talking.
+1. He's either dead or has been tortured.
Trump administration admitted they deported Abrego Garcia by mistake. They stated that Abrego Garcia was deported to El Salvador due to an "administrative error," despite being aware of his protected status from removal.