Hey! OP here. These "goodie bags" are for adults. I am actually highly anti goodie bags at kids parties. I just want them to be able to go through the bag and have a good laugh or memory associated with stuff inside.
I have found some BookIt and Reading rainbow stickers
Etsy has bulk Pogs for sale
Still doing slap bracelets and butterfly clips/tattoo necklaces.
I like the runts idea.
I looked into Tomogachis but was shocked at how expensive they were! I might look into knock offs in bulk.
Are they DC wonky? How about memorabilia from the 92 and 96 primaries? Clinton, Jerry Brown, Paul Tsongas, Bob Kerry, Tom Harkin, Bob Dole, Pat Buchanan, Steve Forbes.
Ha I was just shopping at my local Giant and Garbage was playing and I felt so old. Very day is a 90s party in my head. OP, I would definitely check out Etsy for party favors along this genre and consider whether you’re appealing to kids who hold no connection to the 90s or to the nostalgia of adults.