Anonymous
10/01/2024 00:33
Subject: Does the prestige of the school you’re transferring from matter?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My kid is miserable at an Ivy.
How are chances to transfer to a school like Vanderbilt or Duke or Northwestern?
100% guarantee they will be just as miserable at Northwestern and Duke. We know multiple at those schools
And 3 different ivies(Harvard, Penn, Princeton). They are all harsh for a certain subset of students, yet amazing for others. If yours is not happy at an ivy it is likely they need to change to a school much less competitive such as BC or UVa or UNC. Or an LAC ranked 5-20: still great but not WASP INTENSIVE.
Northwestern seems like a really fun, hopping place according to my kid.
What the school doesn't have is a town full of dive bars that take fake IDs like many small university towns. But campus life is really vibrant and fun.
Perhaps that depends on the personality of the students though. If the kid is an introvert, or a kid looking to get drunk every night at a dive bar, then they might have issues finding their fun.
+1
Anonymous
09/30/2024 08:38
Subject: Does the prestige of the school you’re transferring from matter?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My kid is miserable at an Ivy.
How are chances to transfer to a school like Vanderbilt or Duke or Northwestern?
100% guarantee they will be just as miserable at Northwestern and Duke. We know multiple at those schools
And 3 different ivies(Harvard, Penn, Princeton). They are all harsh for a certain subset of students, yet amazing for others. If yours is not happy at an ivy it is likely they need to change to a school much less competitive such as BC or UVa or UNC. Or an LAC ranked 5-20: still great but not WASP INTENSIVE.
Northwestern seems like a really fun, hopping place according to my kid.
What the school doesn't have is a town full of dive bars that take fake IDs like many small university towns. But campus life is really vibrant and fun.
Perhaps that depends on the personality of the students though. If the kid is an introvert, or a kid looking to get drunk every night at a dive bar, then they might have issues finding their fun.
Anonymous
09/30/2024 08:01
Subject: Does the prestige of the school you’re transferring from matter?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:My kid is miserable at an Ivy.
How are chances to transfer to a school like Vanderbilt or Duke or Northwestern?
100% guarantee they will be just as miserable at Northwestern and Duke. We know multiple at those schools
And 3 different ivies(Harvard, Penn, Princeton). They are all harsh for a certain subset of students, yet amazing for others. If yours is not happy at an ivy it is likely they need to change to a school much less competitive such as BC or UVa or UNC. Or an LAC ranked 5-20: still great but not WASP INTENSIVE.
Disagree with the above post. Much depends upon one's reason/reasons for transferring.
It does, but PP’s list of schools to transfer seem to be nothing more than top Power 4 schools with similar Ivy vibes and student bodies, but with better D1 sports.
Just seems like more prestige seeking vs perhaps really understanding why a kid is miserable at the Ivy and the type of school they really need.