Anonymous
Post 09/17/2024 13:01     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Beadling SC is new this season and it look like they could be worse than Achilles and West Virginia.



Wait you are stating this after one game? Troll



Not at all—these clubs have a long, rich history of being crap. But no need to worry; that shiny MLS Next status means they can keep raking in the $$$$$ regardless!


Please depart this thread and return your busted up ECNL team; salty it was a wonderful program a few years ago. Now it’s long in the tooth. But we are jealous of your schedule. Playing 40% less games a season means you have more time to be, well, ECNL.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2024 21:30     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.


Yet here you are clicking your heals, wishing to be in MLSNext. Troll away, sport.


I'm the person who wrote the above, and my son actually DOES play in MLS Next. Just able to call things objectively, sport.


You’re in MLSNext and you think all losing teams should get the axe? So your standard for player development is wins v losses?

Do you really believe the individual players on those teams are not good at all? That they’re not being developed?

When your DS has played them, was it not competitive at all?


I said two teams do not belong in the league. It's not a matter of wins and losses. It's a waste of resources for a team like the Red Bulls to travel to DC or West Virginia and have a 13-0 match. It serves nobody. You can go 2-20, and that's fine. But most of your games need to be competitive. When you are not providing competition for other teams, you need to move on. NYRB stopped playing WV on age (played their kids up a year) and still spanked the two WV teams. What is wrong with EDP for West Virginia? How did they get accepted to the league? It's a slippery slope to allow clubs like that in...and "club" would be a generous term.


Agreed -- well said.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2024 14:33     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.


Yet here you are clicking your heals, wishing to be in MLSNext. Troll away, sport.


I'm the person who wrote the above, and my son actually DOES play in MLS Next. Just able to call things objectively, sport.


You’re in MLSNext and you think all losing teams should get the axe? So your standard for player development is wins v losses?

Do you really believe the individual players on those teams are not good at all? That they’re not being developed?

When your DS has played them, was it not competitive at all?


I said two teams do not belong in the league. It's not a matter of wins and losses. It's a waste of resources for a team like the Red Bulls to travel to DC or West Virginia and have a 13-0 match. It serves nobody. You can go 2-20, and that's fine. But most of your games need to be competitive. When you are not providing competition for other teams, you need to move on. NYRB stopped playing WV on age (played their kids up a year) and still spanked the two WV teams. What is wrong with EDP for West Virginia? How did they get accepted to the league? It's a slippery slope to allow clubs like that in...and "club" would be a generous term.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2024 13:55     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.


Yet here you are clicking your heals, wishing to be in MLSNext. Troll away, sport.


I'm the person who wrote the above, and my son actually DOES play in MLS Next. Just able to call things objectively, sport.


You’re in MLSNext and you think all losing teams should get the axe? So your standard for player development is wins v losses?

Do you really believe the individual players on those teams are not good at all? That they’re not being developed?

When your DS has played them, was it not competitive at all?
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2024 13:33     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.


Yet here you are clicking your heals, wishing to be in MLSNext. Troll away, sport.


I'm the person who wrote the above, and my son actually DOES play in MLS Next. Just able to call things objectively, sport.
Anonymous
Post 09/16/2024 13:19     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.


Yet here you are clicking your heals, wishing to be in MLSNext. Troll away, sport.
Anonymous
Post 09/14/2024 01:03     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Beadling SC is new this season and it look like they could be worse than Achilles and West Virginia.



Wait you are stating this after one game? Troll



Not at all—these clubs have a long, rich history of being crap. But no need to worry; that shiny MLS Next status means they can keep raking in the $$$$$ regardless!
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 16:25     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Anyone debating MLS-Next vs ECNL vs E64 vs GA vs NAL has their head in the sand.

Check the Copa Rayados East Coast 2024 results there is no MLS-Next or ECNL or EDP pattern of success. What does show is that clubs with large player pools tend to do better than ones that are smaller regardless of league BUUUUUT even then there are exceptions i.e. Burke Athletic U19B.

Until USSF fixes their house no can claim top youth league status.


It also shows these were preseason games.
My sons teams never had their real lineups on the pitch that they are now using in the real season.

Are you saying it's also just a coincidence that the US National Youth teams and big university programs prioritize players from one league over the rest for boys?


I think you are missing the point of what that person stated also that "pre-season" player availability theory affects all the teams in the tournament it is not exclusive to MLS-next teams.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 12:49     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:MLS Next watering down the talent pool. Just like ECNL, CCL, and every other "top" league before it. The cycle continues.


How many men's professional teams playing in the US top league have ECNL youth teams?


Great to have a team, but none of the DCU kids are actually going pro after entering the system at U13. Literally none.


No tesla cybertruck will last 10 years.
Literally none.

(for I too can see the future)
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 12:45     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:MLS Next watering down the talent pool. Just like ECNL, CCL, and every other "top" league before it. The cycle continues.


How many men's professional teams playing in the US top league have ECNL youth teams?


Great to have a team, but none of the DCU kids are actually going pro after entering the system at U13. Literally none.


Nostradamus the Hater has entered the chat.

Though he's right, since DCU doesn't have a U13
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 11:54     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:MLS Next watering down the talent pool. Just like ECNL, CCL, and every other "top" league before it. The cycle continues.


How many men's professional teams playing in the US top league have ECNL youth teams?


MLS Next is not the youth teams of MLS Clubs.


That’s where they play with other top clubs
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 11:52     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:MLS Next watering down the talent pool. Just like ECNL, CCL, and every other "top" league before it. The cycle continues.


How many men's professional teams playing in the US top league have ECNL youth teams?


MLS Next is not the youth teams of MLS Clubs.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 11:50     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:MLS Next watering down the talent pool. Just like ECNL, CCL, and every other "top" league before it. The cycle continues.


How many men's professional teams playing in the US top league have ECNL youth teams?


Great to have a team, but none of the DCU kids are actually going pro after entering the system at U13. Literally none.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 11:48     Subject: Re:New team to enter MLS Next
You have to give credit to ECNL in one regard. If a club (all ages, not just one team) is abysmal, they will give them an ultimatum and then an axe. Will MLS Next be willing to do this going forward? Achilles tells us they aren't thus far, and West Virginia should already have a pink slip.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 11:31     Subject: New team to enter MLS Next
There are teams in the bottom 3 of the Premier League that are not as strong as the top 10

In knockout competition like the Carabao Cup, a 3rd division or 4th division club may beat a Premier League club on a Tuesday afternoon based on a number of reasons

No one with sense is running around saying the Premier League isn't the strongest league with by the most part the best teams

How many ECNL teams in the DMV can go to Florida and play in the Generation Adidas Cup against the best MLS Next Academies and International Academies without getting thoroughly embarrassed?

People, use your brains and not your emotions.