Anonymous wrote:It really depends on your kids, OP: their maturity, how they get along, what they are up to when left home alone. Also, do you have a neighbor or someone relatively close, in case of an (extremely unlikely) emergency?
I'd also definitely make sure that both kids prefer this arrangement to aftercare, and there is an option to reenroll if they change their mind.
I know my kids, if given the option, would come home and have screen time. But I also know more adventurous kids who cannot be trusted alone. Or kids who don't get along well enough, where I wouldn't trust them not to have a fight and one kid to leave or hurt the other kid.
Yeah, I personally would not trust my 6 and 9.5 yr old (4th grader). My 9 yr old is responsible enough to be alone for 20-40 minutes during the day, when alone but he has access to a phone, we live in a safe neighborhood where there are multiple neighbors available on both sides and across the street that could help him and I would stay within 5-10 min. I also instruct him not to cook anything lol. I wouldn’t put that pressure to care for someone else. He’s very much learning and practicing how to be independent in little ways. My kids would miss out on a lot of social time if after school care was taken from them.