Anonymous wrote:It’s always been this way. At some point an older woman usually offers. It’s rarely the men who literally don’t see you (or anyone).
Welcome to noticing what it’s like to be in need on public transportation.
Anonymous wrote:Using a seat for bags is very rude if the train is standing room only.
People on the Metro couldn't care less about allowing those with additional needs to sit, though. I am quite frequently on crutches, either underarm or forearm, and occasionally use a walker, so my disability is quite visible. Even when I've explicitly asked to be given a seat, I have been turned down. Some people who give explanations might be being truthful (such as, "I too have a disability and need to sit, but my disability is Invisible"),`but others just say no, ignore me, or intentionally turn the other way.
Some of those who are seated might have a need to sit, and it's no one else's business what their need is. However, not offering a seat to someone just so you can stretch out or have a place for your bags is very rude.
Anonymous wrote:OP, I took Metro a good bit when pregnant. By far the first people to jump up and offer me a seat were young African American teens. (I am not AA). They wouldn't ask, they would just very politely hop up and usher me right into their seats. I loved each and every one of them and blessed the parents and grandparents who taught them beautiful manners.
One time a lady almost pushed her husband out of his seat so I could sit. But if it wasn't school dismissal time or tourist season with a lot of southerners, then I either stood or had to ask.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:People don't want to offend others by assuming a woman is either pregnant or overweight. So, they don't say anything, and might have assumed a pregnant woman would ask for a seat.
It's neither rude nor presumptuous to move your bag into your lap.
I wasn't talking about the bag/streched leg people. I meant the people in just one seat.
Anonymous wrote:only one quibble! my children had to give up their seats for the elderly, the pregnant, disabled.Anonymous wrote:It's common curtesy to move your bags onto your lap to open up the seat next to you once the train or bus reaches standing room only. No one should have to ask and it shouldn't be something that is only done when someone with a physical disability is present.
It is also curtesy, though not common these days, to get up and give your seat to a child, a parent with their young child, an elderly person, someone who is pregnant, someone with an obvious physical limitation like crutches. You don't have to say anything to call it out. Just get up and make the seat available. If the person doesn't want it, then they won't take it.
only one quibble! my children had to give up their seats for the elderly, the pregnant, disabled.Anonymous wrote:It's common curtesy to move your bags onto your lap to open up the seat next to you once the train or bus reaches standing room only. No one should have to ask and it shouldn't be something that is only done when someone with a physical disability is present.
It is also curtesy, though not common these days, to get up and give your seat to a child, a parent with their young child, an elderly person, someone who is pregnant, someone with an obvious physical limitation like crutches. You don't have to say anything to call it out. Just get up and make the seat available. If the person doesn't want it, then they won't take it.
Anonymous wrote:I have been there 3x - and yes, it's annoying. Especially when the able bodied people rush to get on and take the handicapped seats. The non-able bodied people have to stay back in the rush and make sure they don't get injured!
That said - you should definitely get over asking people to move their bags.
If you get desperate and don't feel well - just say - I'm pregnant and not feeling well, is there anyone who wouldn't mind giving me their seat, and someone will get up or ask the conductor. Once I did that but it was in NYC.
Once, I was 9 months pregnant and literally fought with a man with one leg over the seat - I wanted him to have it, and he wanted me to have it - and no one else observed that and got up! I made him take it in the end.
Once a homeless guy asked me if I wanted him to ask people to give me a seat - it's funny/interesting to see who cares if pregnant people have seats or not.