Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 16:06     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

All met selections are pretty solid
USYNT selections are pretty solid

The mistake most people make is believing that the YNT kid is far superior than than their counterpart that also play at a high level.

High school is not club. There are four age groups combined. A 16 year old YNT kid doesn't always outshine the 18 year old elite ECNL player.



Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 15:48     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

RantingSoccerDad wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


All met isn't plugged into things. HS soccer is social more than anything, especially around here.


So would it be the case that maybe these particular players didn't do much when they were playing for their high schools? Or maybe missed a bunch of games to play with their clubs?

I think if I'm doing All-Met for the Post, I'm checking with every scout and every scouting service I can find. If someone's getting called into national camps, I'm going to say it's safe to assume there aren't 30 better high school players out there.

I did find a couple of their football selections ... idiosyncratic?


It says more about the low level in high school and high school selections than anything else. I know because we watch rec players play over MLSnext and ecnl players all season. Lol
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 15:46     Subject: Re:Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Wtf??

You are strange. And this is an odd post.

Georgia bulldogs, Georgetown, Yale?

It’s such an obtuse and weird post, but it seems you are trying to imply they aren’t good players, correct?

Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 15:27     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ironically - USYNT is more political then all-met.





Politics Yes!!! look none of these players were the key one that helped their team perform. These players had full support and connections, starts with parent, coach, local scout, the guy from social media who ranks players top even when they are average and only cause club has good connections like CEO of US club soccer or US youth Soccer, they are basically the heads of those leagues and of course their clubs are ranked top. FCV avoids playing agains real competition, VDA cheats creating all start teams from different ages recruiting players from other clubs.



All 3 players played in the tournament in France and contributed to the US team winning the tournament. Something is seriously wrong with you. Usually it’s coaches and scouts being abused on here, didn’t know that we were now doing that to kids.
POS

Yeah, all 3 played solid mins and 1 scored 2 goals, but POLITICS! The “tell me you know nothing about” poster(s) on here are clowns…grow up and stop communicating like a 15 y/o 80s valley girl.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 14:36     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Ironically - USYNT is more political then all-met.





Politics Yes!!! look none of these players were the key one that helped their team perform. These players had full support and connections, starts with parent, coach, local scout, the guy from social media who ranks players top even when they are average and only cause club has good connections like CEO of US club soccer or US youth Soccer, they are basically the heads of those leagues and of course their clubs are ranked top. FCV avoids playing agains real competition, VDA cheats creating all start teams from different ages recruiting players from other clubs.



All 3 players played in the tournament in France and contributed to the US team winning the tournament. Something is seriously wrong with you. Usually it’s coaches and scouts being abused on here, didn’t know that we were now doing that to kids.
POS
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 14:08     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Money -- no not al all.

Politics -- might just might get you in the door but not on the team.

Sorry dude. These were the best.


Tell me you know nothing about the actual process without telling me you know nothing about the process....


Cute -- but when people use that expression it means they know nothing at all.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 13:04     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:This is seriously one of the more disgusting threads I’ve seen. Much worse than all the Club and Coach bashing. I’ve never seen these girls play, I have a son in MLS Next ( not DCUnited) who has never been asked to a National Camp or team.
I don’t get any parent who can’t appreciate the work and sacrifice these girls and their families must have made to get to this point. That you’d take out your anger on teenagers because what in your learned opinion your child is better? You are an authority over US and College scouts and coaches?
No system is perfect but seriously how angry and small are you that you can’t just keep your feelings off the internet.
Congratulations to these girls, how great that we’re in an area where this can happen.


Thank you.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 12:55     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

This is seriously one of the more disgusting threads I’ve seen. Much worse than all the Club and Coach bashing. I’ve never seen these girls play, I have a son in MLS Next ( not DCUnited) who has never been asked to a National Camp or team.
I don’t get any parent who can’t appreciate the work and sacrifice these girls and their families must have made to get to this point. That you’d take out your anger on teenagers because what in your learned opinion your child is better? You are an authority over US and College scouts and coaches?
No system is perfect but seriously how angry and small are you that you can’t just keep your feelings off the internet.
Congratulations to these girls, how great that we’re in an area where this can happen.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 12:29     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:Ironically - USYNT is more political then all-met.





Politics Yes!!! look none of these players were the key one that helped their team perform. These players had full support and connections, starts with parent, coach, local scout, the guy from social media who ranks players top even when they are average and only cause club has good connections like CEO of US club soccer or US youth Soccer, they are basically the heads of those leagues and of course their clubs are ranked top. FCV avoids playing agains real competition, VDA cheats creating all start teams from different ages recruiting players from other clubs.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 11:51     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Ironically - USYNT is more political then all-met.



Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 11:32     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Money -- no not al all.

Politics -- might just might get you in the door but not on the team.

Sorry dude. These were the best.


Tell me you know nothing about the actual process without telling me you know nothing about the process....
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 11:32     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Does that go for the other 20 players chosen too?


Probably for many of them. There's a reason for a huge turnover in rosters for USNT players in the college years....


That is silly.


Might be silly, but it is true. Look at the previous YNTs and then look at the WNT rosters and you'll see only a small overlap.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 11:26     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Does that go for the other 20 players chosen too?


Probably for many of them. There's a reason for a huge turnover in rosters for USNT players in the college years....


That is silly.


DP college is amateur part time soccer. It is a path way to nothing.


Soccer for girls in the US is a pathway to college. Which in turn is a pathway for life. Almost all soccer girls could care less about playing pro or for the national team. Sure they would do the national team if they could but almost all are realistic. Even from a young age.
Anonymous
Post 01/18/2024 07:01     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Does that go for the other 20 players chosen too?


Probably for many of them. There's a reason for a huge turnover in rosters for USNT players in the college years....


Is USA the only country with this much roster turnover?
Anonymous
Post 01/17/2024 22:45     Subject: Three Virginia players on US U-17 roster for CONCACAF Championship

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
RantingSoccerDad wrote:All three play high school soccer.

In the spring, one was second-team All-Met and another was honorable mention (granted, both sophomores, but another sophomore made the first team).

In the fall, one was honorable mention All-Met as a junior.

Is this all a fluke of age-grouping, or is All-Met not quite plugged into things? Or has the USSF scouting department overlooked a couple dozen superior players in the DMV alone?

Congrats to all three, in any case. One has signed to play for my Bulldogs. (Well, where I grew up -- can't really say "my" if I didn't go to school there, I guess.)


Politics and money got these three chosen.


Does that go for the other 20 players chosen too?


Probably for many of them. There's a reason for a huge turnover in rosters for USNT players in the college years....


That is silly.


DP college is amateur part time soccer. It is a path way to nothing.