Anonymous wrote:Resurrecting an old thread bc we've struggled (and continue to struggle with) this question! Based on our limited experience the last few years:
Camp Calleva - slightly more diverse than the average sleepaway camp, which tend to skew very WASPy
Camp Friendship - kid loved it, but it seemed more typical of sleepaway camps (reminded me of Get Out (the movie)).
Camp Independent Lake - heard is slightly more diverse than average, but we haven't tried it bc it's quite pricey.
Agree with a PP that sleepaway camps are not a thing for many families of color. (My parents would never have spent money to have us sleep in modest surroundings, although that's clearly changing with my generation.) After Camp Friendship, I realized I really didn't want kid to be the only POC in his cabin and made sure that didn't happen by sending him along with a friend who's also a POC.
OP here... we were at Independent Lake previously but not going back, DS had a backpack with camp stuff (game cards, dice, etc.) stolen two years running. Both times the Camp Director minimized the incident at pickup, told us our kid probably forgot where he put it, that it would show up in lost-and-found, etc. but it never did and he never really followed up with us when we inquired afterwards either. We think there's a bit of willful denial going on there, but benefit of the doubt is this is probably bad luck (and potentially DS being a bit too open with cabinmates about what's in his pack) rather than a rampant issue, but no real way to know. Regardless, it certainly soured our kids' experience enough that we aren't going back. If Camp Director showed more sincere interest in making amends or even acknowledging the problem, he kind of understands that sometimes bad things happen, but felt dismissed rather than supported by camp staff). Is a shame as we had already brought one friend along last year, and possibly would have another this year, plus younger siblings, etc... but I get the sense that they've got such a massive program/pipeline of campers such that they probably don't care much about collateral damage in a few cases like ours, easier just to ignore and move on with status quo.
We did Calleva day camps in prior years and they were OK, but DS said he doesn't want to go there for sleepaway. Didn't give a reason, but just that he thinks it's "kinda mid".
We are trying Camp Friendship this year, we've been there for family camp in the fall and had a good time, so it will be a bit familiar territory at least. A bit concerned how white-heavy the skew is, but again recruited a close friend (non-POC) to join him for camp this year, which should help ensure a smooth experience (we hope!)
As noted in an earlier post in this thread, there are several others that have been mentioned that we'll be considering for next year (or potentially back to Friendship if this year goes well). But I do think camps in Pennsylvania and northward would be a bit preferable due to less hot/humid weather.