Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
You are off. No parent has any control over UCLA, Duke, and UVA unless they are billionaires. Get a grip. These local kids will in fact play. Their goal is to go to college. And play and they will. You are living in a world that does not exist.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Top college teams like Duke/UVA add from 5 to 8-ish new players every year. Every one of them was probably the best player from their ECNL/GA team, but in college they are just one of dozens. The level of play going from club to top college is a big step up. Just making it to the roster is a real accomplishment. There are NFL players who never see the field but they are still impressive, elite players. Someone needs to ride the bench on every team.
Lol no it is not. Go watch them play. As for playing time freshmen are lucky to get a few minutes in a blowout. If you are a junior or senior getting zero minutes it is really time to question what you are doing.
Anonymous wrote:Top college teams like Duke/UVA add from 5 to 8-ish new players every year. Every one of them was probably the best player from their ECNL/GA team, but in college they are just one of dozens. The level of play going from club to top college is a big step up. Just making it to the roster is a real accomplishment. There are NFL players who never see the field but they are still impressive, elite players. Someone needs to ride the bench on every team.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
You are off. No parent has any control over UCLA, Duke, and UVA unless they are billionaires. Get a grip. These local kids will in fact play. Their goal is to go to college. And play and they will. You are living in a world that does not exist.
check the zero minutes at these schools. it exists. it happens every year and NO...they will not play. politics and money for the prestige of the roster spot at a great school. and YES the good players will play. we have a bunch of great players from the DMV. wasn't the point.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
You are off. No parent has any control over UCLA, Duke, and UVA unless they are billionaires. Get a grip. These local kids will in fact play. Their goal is to go to college. And play and they will. You are living in a world that does not exist.
check the zero minutes at these schools. it exists. it happens every year and NO...they will not play. politics and money for the prestige of the roster spot at a great school. and YES the good players will play. we have a bunch of great players from the DMV. wasn't the point.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
You are off. No parent has any control over UCLA, Duke, and UVA unless they are billionaires. Get a grip. These local kids will in fact play. Their goal is to go to college. And play and they will. You are living in a world that does not exist.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
Anonymous wrote:Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Have you seen her play? I've seen a bunch of girls from the DMV commit to top schools (Duke, UVA etc.). They will never play at these schools but the parents have big influence at the schools and get them roster spots. Unfortunately they also blast it all over social media endlessly. Kid gets to school...ZERO minutes. Season over. Soccer career over, but great school. Not really sure why these top D1 programs want practice players at such a low level...can't be good for the team in the long run. There are commitment announcement that are earned by great players with athletic scholarships attached to them and there are commits with all types of behind the scenes efforts to make it to the social media blast that is from a soccer perspective "fake".
Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Agreed, with my DD already committed. She has less interest on showcases and winning nationals than she does to continue on what her college coach has asked her to work on. With 7 commits already on the team, no kid seems to care about winning/losing these games...focus is definitely shifted to individual improvement....I do not think USA youth soccer will ever be set up to give 2 sheets about team winning...it has turned into a college soccer recruiting swamp
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Older ECNL parent here. With the goal of college in mind, even the team performance isn't as important as the individual. It really is all about your DD and playing in ECNL and your club go to pedigree.
On social media I saw a class of 2025 Union player commit to UCLA but the team is nowhere near the top of the mid atlantic let alone nationally.
Agreed, with my DD already committed. She has less interest on showcases and winning nationals than she does to continue on what her college coach has asked her to work on. With 7 commits already on the team, no kid seems to care about winning/losing these games...focus is definitely shifted to individual improvement....I do not think USA youth soccer will ever be set up to give 2 sheets about team winning...it has turned into a college soccer recruiting swamp
And not to say anything is wrong with that in the current model but this is another reason why the women’s national team is on the decline when the top of the pyramid for youth soccer currently is collegiate rather than the senior national team. The collegiate game and the international game are different.
Sure. But the goal for most is college not the national team.
I'd even say the goal of "most" kids who play soccer is to enjoy playing a sport they like. What's the percentage of kids playing in DMV who will go on and play in college? 5%? Yeah, don't even bring up national team, where it's .(lots of zeros)1%
How did we get to a place where everything needs to have an end goal? What happened to just doing things for the enjoyment? I spend a lot of money on golf equipment, family vacations, video games, hobbies, eating out because I enjoy it. They aren’t investments that have an end goal. Soccer is the same thing.
Anonymous wrote:Honestly ECNL or other expensive league is another club experience membership for privileged families. Compare it to a vacation club membership. Likely a low number players would make it and play one or two years at top colleges. The rest would go to low profile colleges or would prefer not to play.