I have one from Quince that I LOVE (cashmere boatneck). I have tried several Everlane sweaters over the years (cotton boyfriend sweater, wool crewneck) and have sold or given away all of them because their crewnecks are so high. They are not flattering and look too masculine to me. I'm a small woman with short hair and a small chest and Everlane sweaters just make me look too boyish for my taste.

5”10 I have both. I definitely prefer quince. Everlane is scratchy and more boxy. I order the men’s quince cashmere in a small and it fits great. I do have a women’s turtleneck too that I also like.

I purchased 2 of these sweaters last February. https://www.everlane.com/products/womens-organic-cotton-crew-sweater-black They have not held up well. The ribbed hem became wavy and looks so worn out now. I'm embarrassed to wear them now so I'm tossing them I reached out to Everlane about how to fix them and they said its too late now, this kind of sweater does not hold up as well as their cashmere or merino wool sweaters, but I don't know if I trust them. I might try Quince next since its half the price. Would rather pay half for 6 months of wear.

Anonymous wrote:I’ve been pleased with my purchases from Quince. Everlane also seems like good quality but never quite fits me right. I don’t think you can go wrong with either depending on what styles you prefer and what fits you best.

I like Everlane but agree their clothes fit a bit off. All of the tshirts I own (long and short sleeved) are a little cropped and boxy, and I need to size up in the pants. I do love the day glove flats.

This is OP. Thank you!!

I'm 5'8" with a long torso and I've found that the basic Quince cashmere sweaters can work if I size up, but the fisherman sweaters are too short.

I have several of both. I think that Everlane is nicer. Their cashmere sweaters have held up very well for me for four years now. The Quince sweaters that I have (cashmere and alpaca) are just a little bit thinner than their Everlane equivalents.

5'9" PP here, the Quince cashmere t-shirt style hit right at the waist for me, but I am fairly short waisted. If you are tall and have a long torso it may be a bit of a cropped look.