Anonymous wrote:She likely started around 275. She's 5'8.
Regarding reward her - what some ppl seem to have issue with - why did she tell us then, if she didn't want it to be a deal?
There are often questions on reddit like "do you want people to mention your weight loss?"
Some responses are on the side of "never mention weight loss unless you're sure it was intentional. It could be illness or depression and some people get self conscious thinking their weight is being monitored by others."
Another camp says "yes definitely! I feel so bad that I have been losing for months and no one even notices. That makes me feel like my hard work was for nothing. Knowing people can tell provides positive encouragement."
I personally have lost significant weight and I am in the first camp. My feeling is I am doing this for myself, not anyone else, and I don't want anyone to comment when I gain or lose. I don't want to be questioned about how I did it (natural way) and why (fear of Covid). I think more people are the opposite of me, though, and want to be noticed.
Your daughter was probably thinking either "ugh, at 50 pounds lost it's obvious enough that I really need to say something and get it over with" or "how the heck have they not noticed I lost 50 pounds! I need to say something so they know about this accomplishment and know I am open to a little positive feedback!"
You would know better than I if she sounded excited, anxious, matter of fact, etc. And you know what her history is and your history as a family.
In an earlier post I suggested texting her and asking if she needs clothes or kitchen things. I would be mortified being offered a reward but others would be thrilled and since she brought it up, I think that's a safe and judgment free way to bring it up.