Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All bone broth is soup, but not all soup is bone broth.

This.

Condensed soup 😋

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:they are not made the same way though

Please elaborate. Thanks!

Bone broth is made by simmering/boiling bones for many, many hours and sometimes days, with a bit of vinegar added to help leach the collagen from the bones. Because of this process, the resulting product is significantly higher in protein and collagen than a stock (and will sometimes gelatinize in the refrigerator), and in fact transferring the protein and collagen from the bones to the broth is the point.

Stock is made by simmering bones and vegetables for 3-4 hours. The point of stock is to impart the flavor of the ingredients, not the nutrients.

Thank you - this is the most helpful answer.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All bone broth is soup, but not all soup is bone broth.

This.

Great syllogism. Now further clarify HOW bone broth is different.

More protein and collagen as stated in the op. Beyond that, Google it!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:they are not made the same way though

Please elaborate. Thanks!

How do you need elaboration??

I make veggie soup by boiling a bunch of veggie scraps and then I add beans and chopped veggies. There are no bones involved. It is not bone broth. Yet it is still soup.

I make fish soup by boiling a bunch of shellfish shells and then adding fish, veggies, and cream. There are no bones involved. It is not bone broth. Yet it is still soup.

You can make chicken soup from boiling the skin and meat from chickens and not include bones. If you do this, you get a chicken flavored soup that is not bone broth. This chicken soup base is fine to make soups where you want a clear broth as your base, like putting in shredded chicken and vegetables.

However, you can also make broth from bones or bones along with meat and skin. When you do this you get more protein and collagen (elements that the broth will get from the bones). It also tends to be less clear and a little more translucent. It is often more flavorful, too.

In general stock is made from a combination of bones, meat and skin. Broth is made from meat and skin, sans bones. I think that companies started selling bone broth under than name because too many people did not know the difference between stock and broth, so they changed the name to be more explicit about whether or not it was made with bones or not.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All bone broth is soup, but not all soup is bone broth.

This.

Great syllogism. Now further clarify HOW bone broth is different.

Bone broth is a broth made by simmering animal bones and/or carcases. Soup is any kind of savory liquid meal. Sometimes soup is made with bone broth. Sometimes it isn't.